When the Best Wine Pairing Isn’t the One You Expected

Four Italian reds, one chicken dinner, and a little lesson in the magic of contrast.

By Claire L. Torbeck, DipWSET

Sometimes the most interesting wine discoveries happen when you’re not particularly looking for them.

When people think of Italian red wine, Chianti often comes to mind. But Italy has so much more to offer, and I wanted to explore some of that diversity over dinner with friends. I deliberately selected four wines made from different grape varieties, representing three Italian regions. The plan was to taste them blind, discover their different personalities, and then revisit them with the same dish to see what changed.

We began with Pieropan Soave Classico and appetizers before moving on to our four reds:

  • 2024 Abbazia di Novacella Pinot Nero, Alto Adige
  • 2023 Vietti Trevie Barbera d’Asti, Piedmont
  • 2022 Tenuta di Nozzole Chianti Classico Riserva, Tuscany
  • 2024 Paolo Scavino Langhe Nebbiolo, Piedmont

Four wines, four personalities, and not an expensive bottle among them. Prices ranged from approximately $23 to $31.

I wasn’t looking for a winner. I wanted everyone to experience how different wines could work with the same dish—and perhaps discover that personal preference has as much to do with successful pairing as conventional wisdom.

An Italian Twist on Coq au Vin

For dinner, I prepared boneless chicken thighs slowly braised with sautéed onions, crimini mushrooms, tomato paste, chicken broth, a little Amador County Barbera, and a few squirts of balsamic glaze. I love balsamic with mushrooms, and the small amount added depth without making the sauce sweet.

The finishing sauce was where things became particularly interesting. I separately sautéed crimini, shiitake, and oyster mushrooms in olive oil, added blistered cherry tomatoes, and incorporated some of the braising liquid, reducing it to concentrate the flavors. A little butter rounded everything out. The chicken was served with garlic mashed potatoes, thyme-roasted carrots, and a light sprinkling of freshly grated Parmigiano Reggiano.

The dish turned out even better than I’d hoped. The mushrooms contributed earthy complexity, the tomatoes provided brightness, and the sauce brought everything together.

Unfortunately, I was also battling a miserable head cold and spent much of the evening blowing my nose while my gracious guests pretended this was perfectly normal behavior for a dinner hostess. Not exactly ideal conditions for evaluating wine aromas, but we persevered!

Four Wines, Four Personalities

We tasted the wines blind before dinner, recording our impressions of appearance, aromas, acidity, tannins, body, and finish.

The Pinot Nero immediately appealed to me with its fresh raspberry, earthy notes reminiscent of wet mulch, cinnamon, and spice. It had high acidity, medium tannins, and a relatively light palate impression. The Barbera was darker, more substantial, and savory, with tobacco and earthy characteristics. The Chianti Classico Riserva and Langhe Nebbiolo were fuller-bodied, with more pronounced tannic structure.

All four had good acidity, although their textures and flavor profiles were quite different. Given the tomato, mushrooms, and savory character of the dinner, I expected the Barbera and Chianti Classico to perform particularly well.

And I wasn’t wrong. But I wasn’t entirely right, either.

Then Came the Food

Every one of the four wines worked with dinner. I could have served any of them and been perfectly happy.

The Barbera and Chianti Classico were harmonious. Their acidity, savory characteristics, and fuller palate presence complemented the food nicely. But they seemed to reinforce what was already happening on the plate. The flavors and textures were compatible without offering anything particularly new.

The Nebbiolo was also very good. Its acidity brought freshness, although its fuller body and pronounced tannins gave it a substantial presence alongside an already rich dish.

And then there was the Pinot Nero.

With each bite of chicken, mushrooms, and mashed potatoes, followed by a sip of Pinot Nero, my palate seemed to come alive again. There was a lift and freshness to the combination that made me want to return for another bite and another sip. The wine didn’t compete with the food, nor did it simply echo the flavors already on the plate. It contributed something different.

Apparently, I wasn’t alone. Three of the four guests who expressed a preference chose the Pinot Nero, while one preferred the Barbera. And when it was time for a second glass, I reached for the Pinot Nero.

When Less Weight Becomes More

I’ve spent some time thinking about why this pairing was so compelling.

The mushrooms certainly played an important role. Their earthy, savory complexity connected beautifully with the Pinot Nero’s earthy undertones. That’s a complementary pairing—wine and food sharing characteristics that reinforce one another. But I don’t think that fully explains what happened.

Consider the dinner. Chicken thighs are richer than chicken breasts. Garlic mashed potatoes are creamy and substantial. Sautéed mushrooms contribute savory depth, while the reduced braising sauce adds another layer of richness. Almost everything on the plate was moving in the same direction: rich, savory, earthy, and rounded.

Now consider the Pinot Nero. It had high acidity, fresh raspberry fruit, medium tannins, and a lighter palate impression than the other wines. Rather than adding another layer of weight, it seemed to restore balance.

The Barbera also had high acidity, so acidity alone couldn’t explain the difference. Its more substantial body and savory flavor profile may have made it feel more like an extension of the dish. The Pinot Nero, on the other hand, offered both an aromatic connection to the mushrooms and a refreshing contrast to the richness of the food.

It complemented the food aromatically while contrasting with it texturally.

A little yin and yang, if you will.

Harmony Versus Excitement

We often approach wine pairing by looking for similarities. A rich dish calls for a rich wine. Earthy mushrooms suggest an earthy red. Tomato-based sauces point us toward wines with good acidity. These are useful principles, but they’re only part of the story.

Instead of asking only what wine has characteristics that match the food, perhaps we should also ask: What could the wine contribute that the food doesn’t already have?

Think about Champagne with French fries. The wine doesn’t taste like potatoes, but its acidity and bubbles provide a refreshing counterpoint to the salt and fat. Or consider sweet Sauternes with salty Roquefort, where the contrast is precisely what makes the combination so compelling.

My Pinot Nero and chicken dinner operated on a similar principle, although much more subtly. The earthy flavors connected, while the wine’s bright fruit and lighter palate weight provided contrast. It wasn’t simply about matching flavors; it was about how the wine changed the experience of eating the food.

Of course, pairing preferences are personal. Someone who enjoys a richer, more seamless combination might reasonably prefer the Barbera or Chianti Classico. All four wines were successful partners, but the Pinot Nero made the food seem more lively to me, and the food, in turn, made me appreciate the wine even more.

A Final Thought

We finished the evening with biscotti and a 2012 Vin Santo (the “holy wine”), a lovely reminder that Italy’s wine diversity extends well beyond its reds.

I’d begun the evening expecting the Barbera and Chianti Classico to be particularly successful with dinner. They were. But the wine that surprised and delighted me was a modestly priced Pinot Nero from Alto Adige—not because it was bigger, more powerful, or more complex, but because its lighter texture and fresh fruit provided exactly what I wanted alongside a rich, savory meal.

Sometimes the magic of pairing comes from similarity. Sometimes it comes from contrast. And occasionally, as with this Pinot Nero, it comes from a little of both.

That’s why I love putting several wines on the table and letting the food have its say.

You never know which bottle you’ll reach for a second time.

A Guide to Extra Virgin Olive Oil: What You Need to Know

Extra virgin olive oil (EVOO) is more than just a kitchen staple—it’s a flavorful, nutrient-rich ingredient with deep cultural and culinary significance. Whether drizzled over salads, used to finish a dish, or simply enjoyed with crusty bread, choosing the right olive oil makes a difference. But with so many terms and labels, it can be difficult to know what to look for. Let’s break it down.


What Is Extra Virgin Olive Oil (EVOO) and Why Does It Matter?

Extra virgin olive oil (EVOO) is the highest grade of olive oil, known for its superior taste, aroma, and health benefits. To earn the EVOO designation, the oil must meet specific standards:

  • Acidity level: EVOO must have a free fatty acid level of 0.8% or lower. A lower acidity indicates better quality and freshness.
  • Extraction method: It must be mechanically extracted (not chemically) using cold pressing or centrifugation, preserving the natural flavors and nutrients.
  • No chemical refining: Unlike lower-grade olive oils, EVOO is not subjected to chemical solvents or excessive heat, which can alter its taste and nutritional profile.
Why Choose EVOO?

Flavor: It offers complex aromas and flavors, ranging from grassy and peppery to buttery and fruity.

Health benefits: Rich in monounsaturated fats and polyphenols, EVOO has anti-inflammatory properties and may reduce the risk of heart disease and stroke.

Authenticity: True EVOO reflects the region, olive variety, and craftsmanship of the producer, much like fine wine.


What Is a Certified Producer and How Do You Identify One?

When buying olive oil, choosing a certified producer ensures authenticity and quality. Certification guarantees the oil meets strict production and labeling standards.

How to Identify Certified Olive Oil:

PDO (Protected Designation of Origin) or PGI (Protected Geographical Indication) labels: These indicate the oil comes from a specific region and adheres to traditional methods.

  • COOC (California Olive Oil Council): If purchasing from California, look for the COOC seal, which verifies the oil is 100% extra virgin.
  • EU Certification: In Europe, look for DOP or IGP labels, certifying the oil’s origin and quality.
  • Third-party certifications: Organizations like the International Olive Council (IOC) and Extra Virgin Alliance (EVA) certify oils that meet strict chemical and sensory standards.

✅ Tip: Beware of misleading labels like “light olive oil” or “pure olive oil,” which are lower-quality, refined oils.


First Pressed, Cold Pressed, or Both? Does It Matter?

You may have seen labels boasting terms like “first pressed” or “cold pressed.” Here’s what they mean:

  • First pressed: This term traditionally referred to the initial pressing of olives, producing the purest oil. However, modern production uses continuous cold extraction methods, making “first pressed” mostly a marketing term today.
  • Cold pressed: This is the important term to look for. It means the oil was extracted at or below 27°C (80°F), which preserves its aroma, flavor, and nutritional content.

💡 Verdict: Choose cold-pressed oil, as it ensures the oil retains its polyphenols and aromatic qualities. The “first pressed” claim is now largely irrelevant due to modern mechanical extraction methods.


Should You Choose Fresh and Young or Aged Olive Oil?

Unlike wine, olive oil does not improve with age. Freshness is key to both flavor and health benefits.

Why Freshness Matters:

Flavor and aroma: Fresh oil offers vibrant flavors—grassy, fruity, or peppery notes. As it ages, it loses intensity and becomes flat.

Nutritional value: The polyphenols, which contribute to olive oil’s health benefits, diminish over time.

How to Spot Fresh Olive Oil:

Harvest date: Look for the harvest date (not just the expiration date). Ideally, buy oil within 12–18 months of harvest.

  • Best by date: Olive oil is best consumed within two years of production. Fresher is better.

✅ Tip: Avoid “aged” olive oil—it’s not a fine wine. Freshness equals quality.


Olive Varieties: How Many Are There and Which Should You Choose?

There are over 1,000 olive varieties cultivated worldwide, with around 150 used for oil production. Each variety brings its own unique flavor profile.

Popular Olive Varieties and Their Characteristics:
  • Arbequina (Spain): Mild, fruity, and buttery with a delicate profile.
  • Picual (Spain): Bold, peppery, and grassy with high polyphenol content.
  • Frantoio (Italy): Herbal and slightly bitter with a robust finish.
  • Koroneiki (Greece): Peppery, herbaceous, and rich in antioxidants.
  • Leccino (Italy): Mild, nutty, and smooth, often used in blends.

💡 Tip: Experiment with different olive varieties just as you would with grape varietals in wine. Taste preferences vary, and some oils are better suited for drizzling versus cooking.


Packaging Matters: Clear Glass or Opaque Container?

Light, heat, and oxygen are olive oil’s biggest enemies. Exposure to these elements accelerates degradation, reducing both flavor and nutritional quality.

Why Choose Opaque or Dark Glass Bottles?
  • Protects from light: Olive oil should be stored in dark glass, tin, or opaque containers to shield it from UV rays.
  • Extends shelf life: Proper packaging helps retain the oil’s flavor and antioxidant properties.
  • Clear glass risk: Oils in clear glass deteriorate faster, especially under store lighting.

✅ Tip: Always choose olive oil in a dark glass or opaque bottle and store it away from direct light and heat.


✅ Key Takeaways for Choosing Quality Olive Oil

  • Choose EVOO: It offers the best flavor and health benefits.
  • Look for certified producers: PDO, PGI, COOC, or EVA seals indicate authenticity.
  • Go for cold-pressed: It preserves the oil’s nutrients and flavor.
  • Fresh is best: Always opt for freshly harvested oil and check the harvest date.
  • Explore different varieties: Try oils from various olive types for diverse flavor experiences.
  • Dark glass or opaque containers only: This protects the oil from light exposure.

The California State Fair hosts an annual Extra Virgin Olive Oil (EVOO) Competition to celebrate and recognize the finest olive oils produced within the state. Here’s an overview: :

1. Certification of Judges:

The competition’s judges are professional sensory evaluators with expertise in olive oil tasting and analysis. Their backgrounds often include sensory science, production, and related fields. To ensure impartiality, all judges must fully disclose any industry involvement and are assigned only to entries where no conflict of interest could be perceived.

Cal Expo & State Fair

2. Blind Tasting Process:

The olive oils are evaluated through a blind tasting process. This method ensures that judges assess each entry solely based on its sensory attributes without any bias. For example, in the 2025 competition, Head Judge Paul Vossen, along with a panel of 15 expert sensory evaluation judges, meticulously assessed each entry based on aroma, flavor, and other criteria.

3. Eligibility of Entrants:

The competition is exclusive to olive oils that are grown, processed, and packaged in California. This focus highlights the state’s rich olive oil industry and ensures that the awards recognize local producers.

In summary, the California State Fair’s EVOO Competition maintains rigorous standards by employing certified judges, utilizing blind tasting methods, and exclusively featuring California-produced olive oils.