When the Best Wine Pairing Isn’t the One You Expected

Four Italian reds, one chicken dinner, and a little lesson in the magic of contrast.

By Claire L. Torbeck, DipWSET

Sometimes the most interesting wine discoveries happen when you’re not particularly looking for them.

When people think of Italian red wine, Chianti often comes to mind. But Italy has so much more to offer, and I wanted to explore some of that diversity over dinner with friends. I deliberately selected four wines made from different grape varieties, representing three Italian regions. The plan was to taste them blind, discover their different personalities, and then revisit them with the same dish to see what changed.

We began with Pieropan Soave Classico and appetizers before moving on to our four reds:

  • 2024 Abbazia di Novacella Pinot Nero, Alto Adige
  • 2023 Vietti Trevie Barbera d’Asti, Piedmont
  • 2022 Tenuta di Nozzole Chianti Classico Riserva, Tuscany
  • 2024 Paolo Scavino Langhe Nebbiolo, Piedmont

Four wines, four personalities, and not an expensive bottle among them. Prices ranged from approximately $23 to $31.

I wasn’t looking for a winner. I wanted everyone to experience how different wines could work with the same dish—and perhaps discover that personal preference has as much to do with successful pairing as conventional wisdom.

An Italian Twist on Coq au Vin

For dinner, I prepared boneless chicken thighs slowly braised with sautéed onions, crimini mushrooms, tomato paste, chicken broth, a little Amador County Barbera, and a few squirts of balsamic glaze. I love balsamic with mushrooms, and the small amount added depth without making the sauce sweet.

The finishing sauce was where things became particularly interesting. I separately sautéed crimini, shiitake, and oyster mushrooms in olive oil, added blistered cherry tomatoes, and incorporated some of the braising liquid, reducing it to concentrate the flavors. A little butter rounded everything out. The chicken was served with garlic mashed potatoes, thyme-roasted carrots, and a light sprinkling of freshly grated Parmigiano Reggiano.

The dish turned out even better than I’d hoped. The mushrooms contributed earthy complexity, the tomatoes provided brightness, and the sauce brought everything together.

Unfortunately, I was also battling a miserable head cold and spent much of the evening blowing my nose while my gracious guests pretended this was perfectly normal behavior for a dinner hostess. Not exactly ideal conditions for evaluating wine aromas, but we persevered!

Four Wines, Four Personalities

We tasted the wines blind before dinner, recording our impressions of appearance, aromas, acidity, tannins, body, and finish.

The Pinot Nero immediately appealed to me with its fresh raspberry, earthy notes reminiscent of wet mulch, cinnamon, and spice. It had high acidity, medium tannins, and a relatively light palate impression. The Barbera was darker, more substantial, and savory, with tobacco and earthy characteristics. The Chianti Classico Riserva and Langhe Nebbiolo were fuller-bodied, with more pronounced tannic structure.

All four had good acidity, although their textures and flavor profiles were quite different. Given the tomato, mushrooms, and savory character of the dinner, I expected the Barbera and Chianti Classico to perform particularly well.

And I wasn’t wrong. But I wasn’t entirely right, either.

Then Came the Food

Every one of the four wines worked with dinner. I could have served any of them and been perfectly happy.

The Barbera and Chianti Classico were harmonious. Their acidity, savory characteristics, and fuller palate presence complemented the food nicely. But they seemed to reinforce what was already happening on the plate. The flavors and textures were compatible without offering anything particularly new.

The Nebbiolo was also very good. Its acidity brought freshness, although its fuller body and pronounced tannins gave it a substantial presence alongside an already rich dish.

And then there was the Pinot Nero.

With each bite of chicken, mushrooms, and mashed potatoes, followed by a sip of Pinot Nero, my palate seemed to come alive again. There was a lift and freshness to the combination that made me want to return for another bite and another sip. The wine didn’t compete with the food, nor did it simply echo the flavors already on the plate. It contributed something different.

Apparently, I wasn’t alone. Three of the four guests who expressed a preference chose the Pinot Nero, while one preferred the Barbera. And when it was time for a second glass, I reached for the Pinot Nero.

When Less Weight Becomes More

I’ve spent some time thinking about why this pairing was so compelling.

The mushrooms certainly played an important role. Their earthy, savory complexity connected beautifully with the Pinot Nero’s earthy undertones. That’s a complementary pairing—wine and food sharing characteristics that reinforce one another. But I don’t think that fully explains what happened.

Consider the dinner. Chicken thighs are richer than chicken breasts. Garlic mashed potatoes are creamy and substantial. Sautéed mushrooms contribute savory depth, while the reduced braising sauce adds another layer of richness. Almost everything on the plate was moving in the same direction: rich, savory, earthy, and rounded.

Now consider the Pinot Nero. It had high acidity, fresh raspberry fruit, medium tannins, and a lighter palate impression than the other wines. Rather than adding another layer of weight, it seemed to restore balance.

The Barbera also had high acidity, so acidity alone couldn’t explain the difference. Its more substantial body and savory flavor profile may have made it feel more like an extension of the dish. The Pinot Nero, on the other hand, offered both an aromatic connection to the mushrooms and a refreshing contrast to the richness of the food.

It complemented the food aromatically while contrasting with it texturally.

A little yin and yang, if you will.

Harmony Versus Excitement

We often approach wine pairing by looking for similarities. A rich dish calls for a rich wine. Earthy mushrooms suggest an earthy red. Tomato-based sauces point us toward wines with good acidity. These are useful principles, but they’re only part of the story.

Instead of asking only what wine has characteristics that match the food, perhaps we should also ask: What could the wine contribute that the food doesn’t already have?

Think about Champagne with French fries. The wine doesn’t taste like potatoes, but its acidity and bubbles provide a refreshing counterpoint to the salt and fat. Or consider sweet Sauternes with salty Roquefort, where the contrast is precisely what makes the combination so compelling.

My Pinot Nero and chicken dinner operated on a similar principle, although much more subtly. The earthy flavors connected, while the wine’s bright fruit and lighter palate weight provided contrast. It wasn’t simply about matching flavors; it was about how the wine changed the experience of eating the food.

Of course, pairing preferences are personal. Someone who enjoys a richer, more seamless combination might reasonably prefer the Barbera or Chianti Classico. All four wines were successful partners, but the Pinot Nero made the food seem more lively to me, and the food, in turn, made me appreciate the wine even more.

A Final Thought

We finished the evening with biscotti and a 2012 Vin Santo (the “holy wine”), a lovely reminder that Italy’s wine diversity extends well beyond its reds.

I’d begun the evening expecting the Barbera and Chianti Classico to be particularly successful with dinner. They were. But the wine that surprised and delighted me was a modestly priced Pinot Nero from Alto Adige—not because it was bigger, more powerful, or more complex, but because its lighter texture and fresh fruit provided exactly what I wanted alongside a rich, savory meal.

Sometimes the magic of pairing comes from similarity. Sometimes it comes from contrast. And occasionally, as with this Pinot Nero, it comes from a little of both.

That’s why I love putting several wines on the table and letting the food have its say.

You never know which bottle you’ll reach for a second time.

A Different Wine, a Different Page in the Mental Rolodex

“There’s no fruit.”

“This wine is terrible. It must be corked!”

Dinner with friends had barely reached the first sip when our wine conversation took an unexpected turn.

Lately, we’ve been enjoying Burgundies and taking a deeper dive into Oregon Pinot Noir—exploring regions, vineyards, and the many expressions of a grape that gives us plenty to discuss. For this dinner, I decided to change things up.

I opened a 2021 red Bordeaux from Graves, a second wine from a château. At around $40, it was intended to be an enjoyable bottle with dinner. Nothing grand. Just a change of scenery.

The first reactions caught me off guard. These were friends with experienced palates, and I hadn’t yet tasted the wine myself. If someone suspected cork taint, I wanted to pay attention.

I looked at the ruby wine in my glass, swirled, and sniffed. The nose was reserved, but I didn’t detect the musty character that would have reinforced the concern about cork taint. With air and a little time, aromas began to emerge. I found fruit, a dusty, savory character I associate with Graves, and a soft, approachable wine.

For me, it was sound and enjoyable: a perfectly pleasant Tuesday-night Bordeaux.

What stayed with me was how quickly we had reached the question of a fault. I wondered whether our recent run of Pinot Noir had left us expecting something different from the wine now in our glasses.

We all carry a mental wine Rolodex. Over time, we collect memories of aromas, flavors, textures, and the bottles that gave us pleasure. Those memories help us recognize what we’re drinking. Sometimes, though, we may still have the previous card at the front of the file.

That’s where taking a moment to look at the bottle can help.

This wasn’t a blind tasting. The label was available to give us our bearings: Bordeaux, Graves, 2021. That information could prompt a useful pause. What have I encountered in wines like this before? Am I finding fruit beneath the savory elements? Does the wine need a little air? What, specifically, makes me suspect a fault?

The label doesn’t answer those questions for us. It gives us somewhere to begin looking.

There’s a distinction here between finding fruit in a wine and describing the wine as “fruity.” Fruit can be present without leading the conversation. Earthy or savory qualities may speak first, with the fruit becoming clearer as we spend time with the glass.

Of course, a familiar appellation cannot guarantee a sound bottle. Cork taint can be subtle, sometimes muting fruit without an obvious musty smell. A suspicion deserves attention. But giving that suspicion a little time—and looking for evidence—can help us reach a more considered judgment.

And recognizing a wine’s style doesn’t oblige anyone to enjoy it. We can understand what’s in the glass and still prefer something else.

For me, the evening was a reminder of how useful our accumulated wine memories can be, provided we pause long enough to consult them. Look at the bottle. Turn a few cards in that mental Rolodex. Swirl, taste, and revisit.

Sometimes a change of wine simply asks us to find our bearings again.

Thanksgiving Wine Pairing: A Few Tips to Keep Everyone Happy

Thanksgiving may be the most challenging meal of the year when it comes to choosing wine. Think about what’s on the table: turkey, stuffing, mashed potatoes, gravy, sweet potatoes, cranberry sauce, and perhaps a few family favorites that make an appearance only once a year.

That’s a lot of competing flavors!

The good news is that you don’t need an expensive bottle or an encyclopedic knowledge of wine to find something that works. Here are four simple tips to help you navigate the wine selections.

1. Offer a Little Variety

If you’re entertaining a crowd, consider offering a white, a red, and perhaps a sparkling wine or rosé. But don’t feel obligated to offer an entire wine shop! A thoughtfully selected white and red will make most guests perfectly happy.

For a white, I’d steer away from the particularly sharp, grassy style of New Zealand Sauvignon Blanc and look instead toward a California Sauvignon Blanc, especially one that includes a little Sémillon. The Sauvignon Blanc offers refreshing acidity, while Sémillon can contribute richness and texture, creating a wine that stands up beautifully to Thanksgiving’s substantial flavors.

2. Acidity Is Your Friend — But Balance Is the Goal

Acidity refreshes your palate between bites, especially when enjoying rich foods such as buttery mashed potatoes, gravy, and stuffing.

But there’s a difference between refreshing acidity and acidity that seems razor-sharp. That crisp, bracing wine you loved with oysters on a summer afternoon might not be your favorite companion for turkey and all the trimmings.

Look for wines with enough acidity to keep things lively, but also some roundness and fruit concentration to complement the meal. It’s all about balance.

3. Give Your Red Wines a Little Chill

Here’s a simple trick: serve your reds slightly cooler than typical room temperature, around 60–65°F. Remember, the wine will warm as it sits in the glass.

This is especially true for Beaujolais, a wine long celebrated as a Thanksgiving companion. Made from the Gamay grape, Beaujolais generally offers bright fruit, lively acidity, and gentle tannins. A slight chill makes those fresh fruit flavors come alive and refreshes the palate between bites.

4. Go Easy on the Tannins

Tannins contribute structure to red wine and create that drying sensation you sometimes feel along your gums and tongue.

Ever left a tea bag steeping too long? That increasingly bitter, drying sensation is a good illustration of astringency from tannins.

Powerfully tannic wines, such as some Cabernet Sauvignon, Nebbiolo, and Syrah, can be challenging with the many flavors of Thanksgiving dinner, particularly sweeter dishes.

Instead, consider reds with gentler tannins, such as Pinot Noir or Gamay (Beaujolais). For whites, Chardonnay, Riesling, and Sauvignon Blanc blends can be wonderful companions.

And Finally, Don’t Overthink It!

Thanksgiving is about gathering around the table, enjoying good food, sharing stories, and making memories.

Whether you’re opening a modestly priced bottle or something you’ve been saving for a special occasion, remember that the company around the table matters far more than the price of the wine.

Choose wines you enjoy, offer a little variety, and don’t worry about finding that one elusive perfect pairing. With so many dishes on the table, there probably isn’t just one!

Happy Thanksgiving, and cheers to making memories and savoring every sip!

When History Sneaks Into the Glass

I spent an evening evaluating a lineup of old Napa Cabernets and kept returning to the oldest wine in the lineup. Remarkably well made for its age, it continued to hold my attention. The next morning, I learned I had been drinking the inaugural vintage of Opus One.


At a Glance

Wine: Opus One 1979
Age: 46 Years
Color: Garnet with sediment; brighter than expected
Aromas: Mint, bottle-aged complexity, oxidative development
Palate: Faded fruit, integrated oak, retained structure and weight
Conclusion: Past its peak, yet still capable of telling its story


The Bottle That Kept Calling Me Back

Recently, we joined friends for an evening of wine and appetizers. As often happens when longtime collectors begin opening bottles that have accompanied them through decades of life, the table became a walk through Napa Valley history. Among the bottles were Groth, Silver Oak, Inglenook, and several others.

One bottle in particular kept drawing my attention: Opus One 1979.

The cork required an Ah-So to remove. In the glass, the wine showed a garnet color with visible sediment and more brightness than I expected from a 46-year-old Cabernet blend. Before pouring, I spent time smelling the bottle opening, as I often do with older wines. While all the bottles offered interesting aromas, I found myself repeatedly returning to the Opus. Despite its age, there was still a lively layer of complexity rising from the neck of the bottle.

My initial impression in the glass was less encouraging. The nose seemed tired and somewhat reductive, showing minty notes along with a faint moldy character that may have reflected the condition of the cork. The wine was clearly showing oxidative development, yet it was far from dead.


Thirty Minutes Changed Everything

Rather than rush to judgment, I let the wine sit in the glass.

Thirty minutes later, the story changed.

The reductive notes had subsided, revealing a wine that had moved beyond its prime drinking window but still carried evidence of what it once had been. The fruit had largely faded, yet hints of former richness remained. The palate retained respectable weight, the oak had long ago integrated into the wine’s structure, and the finish remained surprisingly intact without the excessive bitterness that old phenolics can sometimes display.

When the group asked what I thought, I replied that for a 46-year-old Napa wine, what remained in the glass demonstrated exceptional craftsmanship. While I personally prefer a wine with more fruit than remained here, the fact that it was still drinkable—and still interesting—spoke volumes about its quality.

“Even in a bottle that was clearly past its peak, the wine still possessed enough structure, balance, and character to communicate its origins.”


The Morning After

The surprise came the next morning.

While reading about the partnership between Robert Mondavi and Baron Philippe de Rothschild, I discovered that 1979 was the inaugural vintage of Opus One.

Only then did I realize I had spent the evening with a piece of California wine history.

What struck me most was that I had evaluated the wine before I knew its significance. Had I known I was tasting the debut vintage of one of Napa Valley’s most influential wines, it would have been easy to view it through the lens of reputation. Instead, I simply tasted what was in the glass.

Interestingly, I later discovered that other well-preserved bottles of the 1979 vintage are still showing enough life to impress experienced critics. My bottle was likely more evolved, a reminder that bottle variation becomes increasingly significant as wines approach half a century of age. Yet that fact only reinforced my conclusion.


Why Old Wine Matters

It no longer shouted, but it still had a voice.

As wine lovers, we often ask whether an old wine is still alive. The 1979 Opus One reminded me that perhaps the better question is whether a wine still has a story to tell.

This one did.

Scale Without Sacrifice: Inside Guigal’s Côtes du Rhône

Wine professionals are routinely asked variations of the same question: what is a reliable, reasonably priced bottle for everyday drinking? In practice, the answer often points to wines that are widely available through grocery stores and large retail channels.

Côtes du Rhône frequently enters that conversation. The appellation offers accessibility and broad availability, but it also spans a wide range of production approaches. Not all producers operate with the same priorities.

Having long found E. Guigal’s Côtes du Rhône to perform above its price point, I began to consider what distinguishes it — and how those differences show up in the glass.


A Visit That Reframed the Wine

In October 2022, I stood in Ampuis tasting across the Guigal portfolio, from Côtes du Rhône through Hermitage and Côte-Rôtie.

Like many wine drinkers, I had always associated Guigal with its prestigious Côte-Rôtie bottlings — including the famed La La wines — as well as the structured expressions of the Northern Rhône.

What surprised me most that day was not the top wines.

It was the Côtes du Rhône.

The bottle most consumers encounter on grocery store shelves — often priced under twenty dollars — carried a level of structure and composure that felt distinctly connected to the house’s upper-tier wines. It did not taste like a volume-driven afterthought. It felt deliberate.


The Reality of Scale

Côtes du Rhône is one of France’s largest appellations, and supplying large retail chains requires significant volume. For many producers, the model is straightforward: maximize yields, machine harvest, ferment efficiently, and bottle early to keep inventory moving.

There is nothing inherently wrong with this approach. It produces wines that are approachable, consistent, and ready to drink.

But it is also a model built around efficiency.

Time matters. Extended aging ties up capital. Longer maceration requires labor and attention. Space in a cellar is finite. Every additional month before bottling delays revenue.

Against that backdrop, Guigal makes a different set of choices.


What Guigal Does Differently

Guigal’s Côtes du Rhône is typically led by Syrah, with Grenache and Mourvèdre playing supporting roles. That alone shapes the wine differently. Syrah brings structure, color, and aromatic lift, giving the wine a firmer backbone than many Grenache-heavy blends at this level.

More importantly, the wine is aged for roughly eighteen months, much of it in large, seasoned oak foudres.

These large vessels don’t add obvious oak flavor. Instead, they allow the wine to evolve slowly, integrating tannins and developing texture over time. It’s a quieter influence, but an important one.

At this price point, that level of aging stands out.

It means the wine is not rushed to market. It is given time to come together.


Why It Feels Different in the Glass

When you return to the wine with this in mind, the differences become clearer.

The tannins are present but resolved. The fruit is there, but it doesn’t feel simple or one-dimensional. There’s a subtle savory edge, a sense of structure that carries through the finish.

It doesn’t just taste fruity.

It tastes complete.

That sense of integration is what often separates wines built for quick release from those given time to develop.


A Foundation, Not an Afterthought

What became clear during the tasting in Ampuis is that Guigal’s Côtes du Rhône is not treated as a separate, commercial product.

It is the foundation of the house style.

As you move up through the portfolio, the wines gain in concentration, complexity, and site expression — but they don’t feel disconnected. The same structural through-lines remain.

That continuity matters.

If the entry-level wine were simple or dilute, it would weaken the perception of everything above it. Instead, it acts as a clear introduction to how the house approaches wine.


Why This Matters on the Shelf

For consumers navigating a crowded grocery aisle, not all bottles are created equally — even within the same appellation.

Some wines are built for speed and accessibility. Others are built with a longer view, shaped by decisions that prioritize structure and integration over efficiency.

Guigal’s Côtes du Rhône shows that scale does not have to mean compromise.

It is widely available. It is reasonably priced. And yet, it reflects a set of choices that give it more shape, more balance, and more presence than many of its peers.


Final Thought

At the end of the day, the difference comes down to intent.

When a producer chooses to give even its most accessible wine time — to let it evolve, to let it settle into itself — that decision shows up in the glass.

Guigal’s Côtes du Rhône is not just an easy recommendation because of price or availability.

It’s a recommendation because it quietly delivers more than expected.

Burgundy, Demystified: Why I’m Starting This Journey

Burgundy has a reputation—and in many ways, it has earned it. At its finest, Pinot Noir from Burgundy can be extraordinary: nuanced, layered, and capable of expressing place with a level of precision that few wines achieve.

It is also, quite often, scarce, highly allocated, and expensive.

The most sought-after bottles are produced in small quantities, distributed selectively, and frequently priced well beyond what most of us would consider everyday drinking. Availability can vary widely depending on your market, and even when accessible, these wines tend to be reserved for special occasions.

But Burgundy is not only about its most famous—and expensive—bottlings.

For those of us who love wine but live in the real world, Burgundy offers a range of tiers that are not only more accessible, but also deeply worth exploring.


Understanding the Layers

At its simplest, Burgundy is structured as a hierarchy:

  • Bourgogne AOC
  • Village wines (e.g., Pommard, Volnay, Savigny-lès-Beaune)
  • Premier Cru (1er Cru)
  • Grand Cru

From broadest to most specific, these tiers reflect increasing geographic focus and, in theory, increasing quality.

But as I’ve come to appreciate, classification alone tells only part of the story.

What lives behind a Bourgogne label—or any Burgundy label—can vary considerably. Vineyard sourcing, vine age, farming decisions, and winemaking choices all play a role in shaping the final wine. Two wines with the same classification can deliver very different experiences in the glass.

That idea is what led me down this path.


Why Start at Bourgogne?

In the first installment of this exploration, I chose to begin at the Bourgogne level—not because it represents the simplest wines, but because it offers one of the most interesting opportunities for discovery.

Rather than focusing on larger producers such as Louis Jadot or Domaine Faiveley—both of which produce excellent wines—I narrowed my focus to smaller producers. This is not a question of quality, but of flexibility.

At larger production levels, consistency becomes the priority. House style must be maintained across varying vineyard sources and vintages, which can limit the degree of adaptation in the cellar.

Smaller producers, by contrast, often have the ability to work more closely with their fruit—adjusting extraction, élevage, and blending decisions depending on what each vintage and vineyard parcel offers. In some cases, fruit from higher-tier vineyards may even be declassified into Bourgogne-level wines, adding an additional layer of interest.

The result can be wines that quietly exceed expectations, not by trying to be something they are not, but by being handled with care and intention.


Burgundy for Everyday Drinking

The Bourgogne AOC level also serves a practical purpose.

These wines allow for regular enjoyment. While they are not inexpensive, they are generally priced below many comparable wines from regions such as Napa Valley—particularly Cabernet Sauvignon—and, in my view, often offer greater versatility at the table.

There is a freshness, a sense of balance, and a natural affinity for food that makes them particularly compelling for everyday drinking.


A Different Way to Explore Burgundy

As I began to think more intentionally about how to approach Burgundy, one idea kept coming into focus:

Where is the sweet spot?

Not the most expensive wines.
Not the most famous vineyards.

But the wines that, for a variety of reasons, deliver more than their classification and price might suggest.

This perspective—looking for wines that overdeliver through thoughtful sourcing, careful winemaking, or a combination of both—will guide the series that follows.

It’s a fair question—and one that Burgundy doesn’t always answer easily.


Looking Ahead

Over the coming months, I’ll be exploring Burgundy through this lens—moving from Bourgogne to Village and Premier Cru, and examining where wines truly exceed expectations at each level.

Each installment will focus on a small number of wines, allowing for a closer look at how decisions in vineyard and cellar shape what ultimately ends up in the glass.

Burgundy can feel complex, even intimidating. But it doesn’t need to be.

By starting at the broader end of the spectrum and working upward, the goal is not only to understand the wines more clearly, but to identify where real enjoyment—and real value—can still be found.

Look for the first installment in April:
Finding the Sweet Spot: Bourgogne AOC.

Burgundy’s Quiet Shift: From Extraction to Infusion

Why many Burgundian winemakers are stepping back in the cellar to reveal Pinot Noir’s true character.

Across Burgundy, a subtle change is taking place. Instead of extracting more from Pinot Noir, many winemakers are discovering that patience in the cellar may reveal even more about the vineyard.


A Personal Observation

While preparing several Burgundy masterclasses for 2026, I found myself thinking about how much the conversation around Pinot Noir has changed over the past two decades. When I first began studying Burgundy, much of the technical discussion centered on extraction—how winemakers managed fermentation to build structure and ageability.

Today, however, many producers speak about something quite different: infusion.

The shift may sound subtle, but it reflects a meaningful evolution in how Burgundy’s winemakers approach the cellar.


Extraction vs. Infusion

In wine, meaningful changes rarely announce themselves loudly. More often, they appear gradually—one cellar decision at a time—until suddenly the style of an entire region feels different.

In Burgundy, that shift is happening now.

For decades, discussions about red Burgundy centered on extraction: how much color, tannin, and structure could be drawn from Pinot Noir’s thin skins during fermentation.

Punch-downs, pump-overs, and maceration length were tools used to shape wines that would age gracefully and develop complexity over time.

Historically, extraction in Burgundy was not simply stylistic but practical. In cooler vintages, winemakers often needed to work the cap more actively to build sufficient color and structure from Pinot Noir’s naturally thin skins.

But today, a different philosophy is quietly taking hold across the Côte d’Or. Increasingly, winemakers speak not about extraction, but about infusion.

Extraction implies force. It suggests actively drawing phenolics—color, tannin, and flavor—from the skins during fermentation.

Infusion, by contrast, is a more patient approach. Instead of aggressively working the cap of skins and stems that rises during fermentation, many producers now favor a gentler method. The goal is to allow the wine to gradually absorb structure and aromatics rather than pulling them out through mechanical intervention.

The difference may sound subtle, but in the glass it can be profound.

Infusion often yields wines that feel more transparent and aromatic, with tannins that are fine-grained rather than muscular. Instead of emphasizing power, the wines emphasize nuance.


Infusion and the Shape of Tannins

Another way to think about the difference between extraction and infusion is through the shape of tannins.

Extraction tends to emphasize quantity. Techniques such as frequent punch-downs or aggressive cap management draw more phenolic compounds from the skins and seeds, often creating wines with firmer, more assertive tannic structure.

Infusion, by contrast, is less about how much tannin enters the wine and more about how those tannins integrate. When phenolics dissolve gradually during fermentation—rather than being actively forced out—the resulting tannins can feel finer, more supple, and more evenly woven into the wine.

In practical terms, the wine may not contain less tannin. Instead, the tannins feel different: less angular, more layered, and often more transparent to the vineyard character beneath them.

Because infusion slows the extraction process, it also gives the winemaker more time to observe how the wine is evolving during fermentation. Rather than forcing structure early, the cellar team can allow the wine to develop gradually and intervene only when necessary.

For Pinot Noir, a grape variety prized for its ability to express place, this difference can be critical. The goal is not to eliminate structure, but to shape it in a way that supports the wine rather than dominating it.


Infusion isn’t about extracting less from Pinot Noir — it’s about shaping the tannins differently.


Whole Cluster: Not Just a Beaujolais Technique

The use of whole-cluster fermentation—where grape bunches are placed into the fermenter with stems intact—is sometimes mistakenly associated with Beaujolais.

In Beaujolais, whole clusters are frequently used to encourage carbonic or semi-carbonic fermentation, a process that emphasizes bright fruit and the famously playful aromas often associated with Gamay.

While both Burgundy and Beaujolais may ferment whole clusters, the intention is very different.

In Burgundy, whole-cluster fermentation primarily influences structure, aromatic lift, and fermentation dynamics rather than fruitiness alone. The intact clusters create natural channels within the fermenting must, allowing juice to circulate more gently and encouraging a slower, more gradual infusion of phenolics.

The stems themselves can contribute subtle spice, floral lift, and a distinctive structural backbone to Pinot Noir. When stems are fully ripe—as they increasingly are in warmer growing seasons—they can enhance freshness and complexity rather than introducing bitterness.

In this context, whole-cluster fermentation becomes less about fruitiness and more about texture, aromatic lift, and balance.


Why the Change?

Several forces are driving this shift.

Climate change is one of the most significant. Warmer growing seasons mean that Pinot Noir reaches phenolic ripeness more reliably than it once did. When skins and stems are already mature, there is less need to force structure through extraction.

At the same time, the next generation of Burgundian winemakers has begun taking the reins from their parents and grandparents. Many of these younger producers have inherited not only vineyards but also global demand and escalating land prices. Their challenge is not to make bigger wines, but to preserve the elegance that defines Burgundy’s identity.

In that context, restraint becomes a virtue.


A Region Defined by Patience

Burgundy has long been a region defined by nuance rather than force. As a new generation of winemakers takes the reins—while also navigating climate change, rising vineyard costs, and global demand—their response has often been to do less, not more.

The shift from extraction to infusion reflects that philosophy. Instead of shaping Pinot Noir through aggressive cellar work, many producers now allow the wine to reveal itself gradually.

In Burgundy, patience may prove to be the most powerful tool of all.


Author

Claire L. Torbeck, DipWSET, writes Sudsy’s Cellar to explore how climate, vineyard practice, and winemaking philosophy shape the wines we enjoy.

The Evolution of Your Palate: From Gateway Wine to Adventurous Tastes

Every wine lover has one — the bottle, style, or moment that quietly pulled them into a much bigger world. Before we learned to parse acidity, tannin, terroir, or vintage variation, we had a gateway wine: something that simply tasted good and made us want another glass.

For me, that gateway was White Zinfandel.

Growing up in the Midwest, where wine sales were tightly controlled under the three-tier system, exposure to wine was limited. Like many people, I developed a benchmark based on what was available. Just as your childhood spaghetti sauce becomes the yardstick against which all others are measured, your first enjoyable wine becomes the reference point for everything that follows.

Once I moved past the college “garbage can cocktail” phase and began paying attention to what was actually in my glass, I landed squarely in White Zinfandel territory. But I was already particular. It had to be Sutter Home or Beringer, just sweet enough to be charming but not cloying, low in alcohol, and poured into a proper stemmed glass. Even better, it came from Napa Valley — a name that, at the time, felt synonymous with sunshine, glamour, and endless vineyards. I was hooked.

Not long after, California friends began visiting bringing bottles of red wine, and curiosity took over. Like many drinkers, I gravitated first toward red Zinfandel and Merlot — fruit-forward, supple, and more immediately welcoming than Cabernet Sauvignon. At that stage, I couldn’t have described acidity or tannin, but I knew which wines felt friendly and which felt severe.

Most wine lovers follow some version of this path. Some remain happily devoted to sweeter styles (White Zinfandel, by the way, is still included in Master of Wine and WSET exams — it is a uniquely American category). Others continue on, discovering that acidity makes wine sing with food, while tannin turns a simple glass into something contemplative beside a fireplace and with a cigar.

I vividly remember trying to sort wines into “food wines” and “cocktail wines.” Back then, high-acid wines felt aggressive. Today, they feel like energy, precision, and freshness. The palate evolves.

Even after decades of tasting, judging, traveling, and visiting wineries around the world, we all have a ceiling — for most of us, it’s price. I would love to drink Dujac regularly. I’ve walked the vineyards with Jeremy Seysses in Burgundy, discussing organic and biodynamic farming and the choices he makes to refine his Pinot Noir. But those bottles are aspirational, not everyday.

It’s important to find your own list of go-to wines, but every wine journey begins with curiosity and a palate willing to welcome new tastes. Over time, that curiosity becomes a personal library of flavors, shaped by a growing palate and the pleasure it brings. A gateway wine simply marks where that journey begins.

These days, what ends up in my glass looks very different — but it’s still guided by that same instinct for pleasure and balance.

The following isn’t a comprehensive list — it’s a snapshot of the producers I return to because they consistently deliver wines that express their place, show balance and depth, and offer real drinking pleasure at a fair price.


Claire’s “Wednesday Wines” — because not every bottle has to be a Saturday night splurge

  • Chardonnay — Joseph Drouhin Domaine Vaudon Chablis
  • Chardonnay (USA) — Chateau Montelena Napa Valley Chardonnay
  • Bordeaux (Cabernet Blend) — Château Lilian Ladouys, Saint-Estèphe
  • Syrah — Saint-Cosme Côtes du Rhône
  • Barbera — Vietti Barbera d’Asti Trevì
  • Barbera (USA) — Scott Harvey Barbera, Sierra Foothills
  • Nebbiolo — Vietti Perbacco Langhe Nebbiolo
  • Sangiovese — Castello di Monsanto Chianti Classico Riserva
  • Riesling — Dr. Loosen “Dr. L” Riesling 2023
  • Tempranillo — Marqués de Riscal Rioja Reserva
  • Pinot Noir — Louis Latour Marsannay Rouge
  • Pinot Noir (USA) — Au Bon Climat Santa Barbara County Pinot Noir

Most of these wines aren’t American — not because California lacks quality, but because certain grapes and styles are more faithfully expressed, and more affordably delivered, in their historic homes.

Wine appreciation isn’t about abandoning where you started. It’s about letting that first spark of curiosity carry you somewhere deeper.

So I’ll ask you:

What was your gateway wine?


What Is a Gateway Wine?

A gateway wine is the bottle or style that first made wine feel pleasurable rather than puzzling. It isn’t necessarily complex, expensive, or prestigious — it’s simply the wine that made you want a second glass.

Gateway wines tend to share a few traits:

  • Approachable fruit flavors
  • Low bitterness or tannin
  • Easy drinking without needing food or analysis

For many Americans, that gateway might be White Zinfandel, Moscato d’Asti, sweet Riesling, or a fruit-forward red like Merlot or Zinfandel. These wines create positive emotional memory — and once that association forms, curiosity naturally follows.

Over time, most drinkers move toward drier, more structured, or more site-driven wines, but the gateway wine still matters. It built the bridge between “I don’t really drink wine” and “I enjoy wine.”

In that sense, every serious wine journey begins with something simple — and that’s not a weakness, it’s how palates are made.

The Evolving Landscape of Global Wine: Climate vs. Market

Wine has always evolved. But over the past several decades, the pace—and direction—of stylistic change has accelerated. Across the globe, wines have grown riper, darker, more structured, and often more oak-influenced. Alcohol levels have edged upward. Texture and immediacy increasingly take precedence over restraint.

The question many wine professionals quietly ask is this:
Are these changes driven primarily by climate change—or by market forces shaped by critics, scores, and consumer demand?

The honest answer is not either/or. It is both.


Where Climate Ends and Choice Begins

Climate change is no longer abstract in the vineyard; it is measurable and unavoidable. Earlier budbreak, compressed growing seasons, rising sugar levels, faster phenolic development, and increasing water stress are now common realities across many of the world’s established wine regions.

These shifts naturally influence grape composition and harvest decisions. In many cases, wines are becoming riper not by design, but by necessity.

Yet climate alone does not dictate style.

While environmental conditions define what is possible, they do not determine what is pursued. That distinction belongs to the winemaker—and, increasingly, to the market.


The Market Pull: When Style Becomes Strategy

As global wine markets expanded, a powerful feedback loop emerged between critics, scores, and consumer expectations. Wines that were richer, more expressive, and immediately impactful tended to score well—and sell well. Over time, stylistic preferences hardened into commercial strategy.

Oak regimes shifted. Extraction increased. Alcohol levels crept upward. Even regions historically associated with restraint began producing wines designed to perform on release rather than evolve quietly over time.

These changes were not inherently negative. They were, in many cases, pragmatic responses to a competitive global marketplace. But they also blurred distinctions between regions, encouraging a convergence of style that made wines more recognizable—and sometimes more interchangeable.

The most consequential moment occurs when climate pressure and market incentives move in the same direction. Warmer growing conditions naturally produce riper fruit; market demand rewards richness and intensity. What appears inevitable can, in fact, be amplified by choice.


Same Region, Two Philosophies: Rioja

Few regions illustrate this intersection of climate, market forces, and human intention more clearly than Rioja DOCa.

For much of its history, traditional Rioja defined itself not by power, but by patience. Long aging in American oak created an oxidative environment where complexity emerged through time rather than fruit intensity. Extended maturation—often carried out at the winery’s expense—allowed wines to develop tertiary aromas of leather, dried fruit, tobacco, and earth. These wines were typically medium-bodied, softly structured, and released only when considered ready to drink.

Modern Rioja reflects a different set of priorities. While remaining within DOCa aging requirements, many producers shifted toward French oak, shorter maturation cycles, reduced maceration, and increased focus on freshness and structure. Fruit expression became more pronounced; tannins firmer; acidity brighter. Single-varietal bottlings and experimental blends emerged alongside traditional styles.

The result is not a divided region, but a pluralistic one—where philosophy, not regulation, defines expression.


A Quiet Counter-Movement

Alongside these trends, a quieter movement has gained momentum. Some producers, faced with warming conditions, are choosing restraint rather than amplification. Earlier harvests, larger or neutral vessels, gentler extraction, and site-driven decision-making aim to preserve identity rather than polish it away.

These wines may not always dominate tastings or score highest on release. But they reward patience, food, and attention—and they remind us that evolution need not mean homogenization.


Closing: Evolution Is Inevitable. Homogenization Is Not.

Wine will continue to evolve; climate ensures that. But climate does not make stylistic decisions—people do. Vineyard conditions may push grapes toward ripeness, yet it is philosophy, commercial pressure, and producer intent that determine how that ripeness is expressed in the glass.

The most compelling wines today are not defined by whether they are traditional or modern, powerful or restrained. They are defined by clarity of intent. In an era where climate realities and market incentives increasingly align, the risk is not change itself, but convergence—the quiet erosion of distinction in favor of familiarity.

For the drinker, this moment invites curiosity rather than judgment. Asking why a wine tastes the way it does may be more revealing than deciding whether one style is better than another. After all, evolution can deepen identity just as easily as it can blur it—and the difference lies not only in the vineyard, but in the choices made long after the grapes are harvested.

An Exercise in Style: Traditional vs. Modern Rioja

To explore how winemaking philosophy shapes style within a single region, consider tasting wines from producers that represent different approaches within Rioja DOCa. These examples are illustrative rather than prescriptive; they highlight intent, not hierarchy.

Traditional-Leaning Rioja Producers

(Extended aging, American oak influence, late-release philosophy)

  • López de Heredia
    A benchmark for long oxidative aging, American oak, and winery-held releases that prioritize tertiary development and readiness at release.
  • La Rioja Alta
    Classical blending, in-house cooperage, and extended maturation defining traditional Rioja structure, aromatics, and longevity.
  • CVNE
    A historic house whose core bottlings continue to reflect restrained fruit expression and traditional aging practices.

Modern-Leaning Rioja Producers

(Freshness, structure, fruit clarity, and precision)

  • Artadi
    Site-focused wines emphasizing purity of fruit, reduced oak influence, and early clarity of expression.
  • Bodegas Muga
    A compelling example of modern Rioja that retains deep respect for tradition—combining contemporary precision, in-house cooperage, and a focus on freshness and structure.
  • Marqués de Riscal
    A historic estate illustrating how traditional roots can coexist with modern techniques and global markets.

How to Use This Exercise

Taste one wine from each category side by side. Focus not on preference, but on why the wines differ:

  • How does oak choice influence aroma, texture, and perception of freshness?
  • What role does time—both in barrel and bottle—play in complexity versus immediacy?
  • How does each wine communicate its intended moment of consumption?

The goal is not to crown a winner, but to understand how climate, market forces, and producer philosophy intersect to shape what ends up in the glass.


I have recently visited the wineries and vineyards of these producers, offering first-hand insight into how philosophy translates from vineyard to cellar.

“These producers illustrate stylistic choices—not quality hierarchies.”

What Petite Sirah Does to Cabernet—And Why It Matters

“Cabernet Sauvignon is a soloist. So why do so many winemakers keep giving it backup singers?”



In the ever-competitive world of California wine, consistency is currency. With rising expectations from consumers and critics alike, wineries often seek to craft Cabernet Sauvignon wines that are plush, powerful, and polished—vintage after vintage. But in the pursuit of this stylistic consistency, an unlikely grape has become a quiet enabler: Petite Sirah.

Blended in small but influential amounts, Petite Sirah is frequently added to Cabernet to deepen color, round out texture, and stabilize structure. Yet in doing so, it may also be flattening acidity, muting fruit expression, and ultimately dulling the vibrant voice that great Cabernet is capable of singing.

This article explores what Petite Sirah does in the blend, how its use reflects a formulaic winemaking mindset, and why this quiet shift in cellar choices matters—for authenticity, terroir transparency, and the future of expressive wines.

The Quiet Power of Petite Sirah

Petite Sirah (a.k.a. Durif) is a thick-skinned, late-ripening varietal known for its deeply pigmented juice, high tannin content, and bold structure. While seldom bottled on its own in high-end blends, it is a favorite tool for winemakers looking to:
– Intensify color
– Boost tannin grip
– Round out mouthfeel
– Stabilize a wine’s profile

Yet these benefits come with trade-offs. When added to Cabernet—even in small amounts—Petite Sirah can:
– Mute bright red or cassis fruit
– Suppress varietal clarity
– Dampen perceived acidity
– Create a generalized ‘bigness’ rather than detailed expression

As one winemaker privately put it, “It’s the volume button, not the tuning knob.”

From Character to Consistency: The Rise of Formula Wine

In vertical tastings, one can often detect when a wine’s profile becomes more about replicating house style than reflecting vintage variation or vineyard nuance. It’s here that Petite Sirah plays its stealth role.

There are brands that frequently rely on blending components like Petite Sirah, Syrah, or even Zinfandel to maintain plush, rounded profiles. The goal? Appealing mouthfeel, saturated color, and a flavor profile that “delivers” reliably at the retail shelf.

This is the hallmark of what I call formula wine—a blend crafted to meet expectations, not challenge them. And while there’s no shame in making delicious, accessible wine, it raises the question: At what point does formula replace authenticity?

When Cabernet Speaks, Listen Closely

Cabernet Sauvignon, when grown in the right site and allowed to express itself, can be electrifying: lifted aromas of blackcurrant, graphite, tobacco leaf, and violets; vibrant acidity; age-worthy tannin structure. These are the hallmarks of expressive Cabernet—from Napa’s mountain vineyards to Paso’s limestone pockets to Bordeaux’s Left Bank.

But once you’ve tasted a site-pure, unembellished Cabernet, it becomes hard to ignore how muted some blends have become. That exhilarating brightness—what some call “the snap”—can disappear under a thick cloak of color, weight, and indistinct darkness.

I’ve personally tasted Cabernets from producers who add Petite Sirah that feel like flat soda—dense, heavy, and short on lift. The freshness is gone. The fruit is thick, not bright. And while the wine may impress in a tasting lineup, it rarely invites a second glass at the dinner table.

Who’s Doing It Differently: Site Over Style

Fortunately, not all Cabernet producers follow the formula. A growing number of winemakers are leaning into transparency over technique—choosing to let vineyard expression and vintage variation shine, even if that means sacrificing some polish or consistency.

Take producers like Corison in Napa Valley. Cathy Corison’s wines are resolutely varietal, often lower in alcohol, and proudly site-driven. Her Kronos Vineyard Cabernets taste like where they come from—gravelly soils just west of Highway 29, exposed to the diurnal shifts that preserve acidity and aromatic lift.

Ridge Vineyards, while more commonly associated with Zinfandel, produces Cabernets from sites like Monte Bello with admirable restraint, complexity, and no need to “flesh out” the wine with extraneous blending or high-octane stylization.

Producers like Smith-Madrone, Heitz Cellar, Keenan, and Dunn Vineyards offer Cabernets that maintain integrity to site and vintage. These wines resist manipulation, embracing structure, freshness, and varietal clarity—without needing to “supercharge” with Petite Sirah or overdone oak.

These producers understand something critical: that the best Cabernet doesn’t need to be louder—it needs to be clearer.

Perspective and Palate

Let’s be clear: wine is ultimately a beverage meant to be enjoyed, and there are many different palates to please. Styled wines absolutely have their place—especially for newer consumers or in restaurant programs, where reliability and approachability are often more important than vintage variation or site expression.

That said, in marketing their brands, some winemakers—particularly in regions like Paso Robles—blend in Syrah or Petite Sirah and present the resulting wines as superior-quality, classic, and ageworthy Cabernets, often described as exquisitely rich and elegant, capable of rivaling their famous French counterparts.

Are those claims justified? That’s a question each consumer, sommelier, or collector must answer for themselves. But asking the question is part of being an engaged wine drinker—and part of honoring the diversity of what Cabernet Sauvignon can be.

Why It Matters

The use of Petite Sirah in Cabernet might seem like a minor cellar decision. But in the broader context of modern winemaking, it represents a choice: Are we crafting wines to reflect a place—or to meet a profile?

When the goal is to achieve consistency at all costs, we drift into a territory where wines are built, not born. And while there is undoubtedly a place for plush, approachable styles, the danger lies in the erasure of nuance and identity. As blending becomes a tool for engineering sameness, we risk losing the very character that makes great Cabernet—from Howell Mountain to Happy Canyon—so compelling.

As a wine judge, writer, and sommelier, I’ve come to value wines that tell the truth—even when that truth is leaner, edgier, or more angular than expected. I’d rather taste the vineyard in a minor key than hear the same chorus on repeat.

Petite Sirah is not the villain. But its quiet role in muting Cabernet’s natural voice deserves more attention—and more conversation.

Final Sip

If you’ve opened a bottle of Cabernet lately and found it heavy, indistinct, or curiously lifeless, ask yourself: Is this wine speaking, or has its voice been replaced?

Wine doesn’t need to shout to be heard. Sometimes, all it needs is the courage to be itself.

Author’s Note

This piece reflects one sommelier’s perspective on how blending choices and stylistic decisions can shape the personality of a wine. It’s not a criticism of blending or of winemakers who pursue a consistent house style — rather, it’s a reflection on how expression, balance, and individuality can coexist within the craft of winemaking.