Dinner with friends had barely reached the first sip when our wine conversation took an unexpected turn.
Lately, we’ve been enjoying Burgundies and taking a deeper dive into Oregon Pinot Noir—exploring regions, vineyards, and the many expressions of a grape that gives us plenty to discuss. For this dinner, I decided to change things up.
I opened a 2021 red Bordeaux from Graves, a second wine from a château. At around $40, it was intended to be an enjoyable bottle with dinner. Nothing grand. Just a change of scenery.
The first reactions caught me off guard. These were friends with experienced palates, and I hadn’t yet tasted the wine myself. If someone suspected cork taint, I wanted to pay attention.
I looked at the ruby wine in my glass, swirled, and sniffed. The nose was reserved, but I didn’t detect the musty character that would have reinforced the concern about cork taint. With air and a little time, aromas began to emerge. I found fruit, a dusty, savory character I associate with Graves, and a soft, approachable wine.
For me, it was sound and enjoyable: a perfectly pleasant Tuesday-night Bordeaux.
What stayed with me was how quickly we had reached the question of a fault. I wondered whether our recent run of Pinot Noir had left us expecting something different from the wine now in our glasses.
We all carry a mental wine Rolodex. Over time, we collect memories of aromas, flavors, textures, and the bottles that gave us pleasure. Those memories help us recognize what we’re drinking. Sometimes, though, we may still have the previous card at the front of the file.
That’s where taking a moment to look at the bottle can help.
This wasn’t a blind tasting. The label was available to give us our bearings: Bordeaux, Graves, 2021. That information could prompt a useful pause. What have I encountered in wines like this before? Am I finding fruit beneath the savory elements? Does the wine need a little air? What, specifically, makes me suspect a fault?
The label doesn’t answer those questions for us. It gives us somewhere to begin looking.
There’s a distinction here between finding fruit in a wine and describing the wine as “fruity.” Fruit can be present without leading the conversation. Earthy or savory qualities may speak first, with the fruit becoming clearer as we spend time with the glass.
Of course, a familiar appellation cannot guarantee a sound bottle. Cork taint can be subtle, sometimes muting fruit without an obvious musty smell. A suspicion deserves attention. But giving that suspicion a little time—and looking for evidence—can help us reach a more considered judgment.
And recognizing a wine’s style doesn’t oblige anyone to enjoy it. We can understand what’s in the glass and still prefer something else.
For me, the evening was a reminder of how useful our accumulated wine memories can be, provided we pause long enough to consult them. Look at the bottle. Turn a few cards in that mental Rolodex. Swirl, taste, and revisit.
Sometimes a change of wine simply asks us to find our bearings again.
Why many Burgundian winemakers are stepping back in the cellar to reveal Pinot Noir’s true character.
Across Burgundy, a subtle change is taking place. Instead of extracting more from Pinot Noir, many winemakers are discovering that patience in the cellar may reveal even more about the vineyard.
A Personal Observation
While preparing several Burgundy masterclasses for 2026, I found myself thinking about how much the conversation around Pinot Noir has changed over the past two decades. When I first began studying Burgundy, much of the technical discussion centered on extraction—how winemakers managed fermentation to build structure and ageability.
Today, however, many producers speak about something quite different: infusion.
The shift may sound subtle, but it reflects a meaningful evolution in how Burgundy’s winemakers approach the cellar.
Extraction vs. Infusion
In wine, meaningful changes rarely announce themselves loudly. More often, they appear gradually—one cellar decision at a time—until suddenly the style of an entire region feels different.
In Burgundy, that shift is happening now.
For decades, discussions about red Burgundy centered on extraction: how much color, tannin, and structure could be drawn from Pinot Noir’s thin skins during fermentation.
Punch-downs, pump-overs, and maceration length were tools used to shape wines that would age gracefully and develop complexity over time.
Historically, extraction in Burgundy was not simply stylistic but practical. In cooler vintages, winemakers often needed to work the cap more actively to build sufficient color and structure from Pinot Noir’s naturally thin skins.
But today, a different philosophy is quietly taking hold across the Côte d’Or. Increasingly, winemakers speak not about extraction, but about infusion.
Extraction implies force. It suggests actively drawing phenolics—color, tannin, and flavor—from the skins during fermentation.
Infusion, by contrast, is a more patient approach. Instead of aggressively working the cap of skins and stems that rises during fermentation, many producers now favor a gentler method. The goal is to allow the wine to gradually absorb structure and aromatics rather than pulling them out through mechanical intervention.
The difference may sound subtle, but in the glass it can be profound.
Infusion often yields wines that feel more transparent and aromatic, with tannins that are fine-grained rather than muscular. Instead of emphasizing power, the wines emphasize nuance.
Infusion and the Shape of Tannins
Another way to think about the difference between extraction and infusion is through the shape of tannins.
Extraction tends to emphasize quantity. Techniques such as frequent punch-downs or aggressive cap management draw more phenolic compounds from the skins and seeds, often creating wines with firmer, more assertive tannic structure.
Infusion, by contrast, is less about how much tannin enters the wine and more about how those tannins integrate. When phenolics dissolve gradually during fermentation—rather than being actively forced out—the resulting tannins can feel finer, more supple, and more evenly woven into the wine.
In practical terms, the wine may not contain less tannin. Instead, the tannins feel different: less angular, more layered, and often more transparent to the vineyard character beneath them.
Because infusion slows the extraction process, it also gives the winemaker more time to observe how the wine is evolving during fermentation. Rather than forcing structure early, the cellar team can allow the wine to develop gradually and intervene only when necessary.
For Pinot Noir, a grape variety prized for its ability to express place, this difference can be critical. The goal is not to eliminate structure, but to shape it in a way that supports the wine rather than dominating it.
Infusion isn’t about extracting less from Pinot Noir — it’s about shaping the tannins differently.
Whole Cluster: Not Just a Beaujolais Technique
The use of whole-cluster fermentation—where grape bunches are placed into the fermenter with stems intact—is sometimes mistakenly associated with Beaujolais.
In Beaujolais, whole clusters are frequently used to encourage carbonic or semi-carbonic fermentation, a process that emphasizes bright fruit and the famously playful aromas often associated with Gamay.
While both Burgundy and Beaujolais may ferment whole clusters, the intention is very different.
In Burgundy, whole-cluster fermentation primarily influences structure, aromatic lift, and fermentation dynamics rather than fruitiness alone. The intact clusters create natural channels within the fermenting must, allowing juice to circulate more gently and encouraging a slower, more gradual infusion of phenolics.
The stems themselves can contribute subtle spice, floral lift, and a distinctive structural backbone to Pinot Noir. When stems are fully ripe—as they increasingly are in warmer growing seasons—they can enhance freshness and complexity rather than introducing bitterness.
In this context, whole-cluster fermentation becomes less about fruitiness and more about texture, aromatic lift, and balance.
Why the Change?
Several forces are driving this shift.
Climate change is one of the most significant. Warmer growing seasons mean that Pinot Noir reaches phenolic ripeness more reliably than it once did. When skins and stems are already mature, there is less need to force structure through extraction.
At the same time, the next generation of Burgundian winemakers has begun taking the reins from their parents and grandparents. Many of these younger producers have inherited not only vineyards but also global demand and escalating land prices. Their challenge is not to make bigger wines, but to preserve the elegance that defines Burgundy’s identity.
In that context, restraint becomes a virtue.
A Region Defined by Patience
Burgundy has long been a region defined by nuance rather than force. As a new generation of winemakers takes the reins—while also navigating climate change, rising vineyard costs, and global demand—their response has often been to do less, not more.
The shift from extraction to infusion reflects that philosophy. Instead of shaping Pinot Noir through aggressive cellar work, many producers now allow the wine to reveal itself gradually.
In Burgundy, patience may prove to be the most powerful tool of all.
Author
Claire L. Torbeck, DipWSET, writes Sudsy’s Cellar to explore how climate, vineyard practice, and winemaking philosophy shape the wines we enjoy.
Thanksgiving is a time to gather with loved ones, celebrate gratitude, and savor an indulgent feast. Wine plays a crucial role in elevating the meal, complementing the rich array of flavors on the table. Whether you’re looking for an affordable crowd-pleaser, a mid-range gem, or a luxurious splurge, we’ve got you covered. Here are some recommendations for every budget.
Sparkling Wines: Welcome Friends and Family
Basic: Campo Viejo Cava Brut Reserve ($12-$15)
Cava from Spain is a vibrant, zesty white with citrus and stone fruit notes. It pairs wonderfully with turkey, stuffing, and lighter sides like green beans or salad, offering excellent value. Clean and refreshing finish with a well-balanced acidity.
Mid-Range: Roederer Estate Brut NV ($18-$24)
Roederer Estate sparkling wines are known for their complexity, elegance, and balance, much like their Champagne counterparts. Bright citrus, green apple, and pear dominate, with subtle raspberry nuances from Pinot Noir with a touch of brioche.
Splurge: Pommery Brut Royal Champagne ($55-$60)
Pale golden yellow with a fine, persistent mousse. Light to medium-bodied with a crisp, dry profile. Flavors of citrus, green apple, and white peach. An excellent introduction to the house’s refined Champagne style and a delightful choice for both casual and formal occasions.
White Wines: Perfect for Turkey and Sides
Basic: Pine Ridge Chenin Blanc + Viognier White Blend ($12-$15)
Juicy and refreshing, with flavors of ripe melon, green apple, and tropical fruits like pineapple. Known for its excellent quality-to-price ratio, this blend’s versatility makes it a fantastic pairing for various dishes:
Mid-Range: Hugel Classic Gewurztraminer ($25–$28)
This aromatic white grape is prized for its bold, floral and spicy character making it a great choice for Thanksgiving fare. Aromatic, and slightly off-dry make it a versatile pairing wine.
Splurge: Louis Jadot Chablis Fourchaume Premier Cru ($55+)
This single-varietal chardonnay wine showcases the purity and elegance of Chablis’ terroir, emphasizing freshness and minerality. Flavors of citrus zest, white peach, and crisp apple dominate, but with a creamy richness on the palate. Pure delight!
Red Wines: For the Heartier Dishes – Beaujolais Anyone?
Basic: Georges Duboeuf Beaujolais Nouveau ($10–$15)
Fresh, fruity, and easy-drinking, Beaujolais Nouveau is a classic choice for Thanksgiving. Its light body and vibrant red fruit notes harmonize with cranberry sauce and roasted turkey.
Mid-Range: Chateau des Deduits Fleurie Beaujolais ($22-$25)
Fleurie, known as the ‘Queen of Beaujolais Crus,’ produces wines that are typically lighter, fragrant, and more delicate than some of the other Crus. Floral hints of violets and roses, with subtle earthy and spicy notes such as white pepper and a touch of licorice.
Splurge: Domaine Jean Foillard Morgon Cote du Py Beaujolais ($52+)
Morgon is one of the 10 Crus of Beaujolais, known for producing structured, age-worthy wines. Ripe red and dark fruits, cherry, raspberry, and blackcurrant with earthy notes of wet stone, forest floor, and subtle mushroom.
more red wines: Pinot noir to please
Basic: Four Graces Pinot Noir Willamette Valley ($12-$25)
Medium-bodied with a smooth, velvety texture. Fresh red fruit flavors of cranberry, cherry, and plum and an earthy complexity balanced with vibrant acidity.
Mid-Range: Roserock by Drouhin Oregon Eola-Amity Hills Pinot Noir ($40+)
This wine is an exceptional expression of Oregon terroir, combining the finesse of Burgundy with the distinct characteristics of the Eola-Amity Hills. It’s a refined, balanced Pinot Noir that offers both elegance and depth, making it perfect for those who appreciate both the new world and old world styles of Pinot Noir. Elegant and complex, showcasing a beautiful balance of fruit, earthiness, and subtle spice
Splurge: Louis Jadot Santenay Clos de Malte, Burgundy ($55-$60)
Clos de Malte: This specific vineyard, classified as a Premier Cru, is a monopole (single-vineyard site) owned by Louis Jadot. The terroir of Clos de Malte is particularly favored for its warm, south-facing exposure, ensuring that the grapes ripen fully while maintaining good acidity. A classic Burgundy Pinot Noir, offering a beautiful balance of fruit, earth, and spice.
Dessert Wines: The Grand Finale
Basic: Croft Reserve Tawny Porto ($20-$25)
A classic, well-balanced Tawny Port with rich dried fruit, nutty flavors, and a smooth, velvety texture. Reserve Tawny Port: This is typically a blend of Ports aged in oak for around 5 to 7 years, though it can vary slightly.
Mid-Range: Graham’s 10 yr. Tawny Port ($30+)
The Graham’s 10 Year Old Tawny Port is a standout in the category of aged Tawny Ports, offering a refined balance of fruit, nutty flavors, and the signature complexity that comes with extended aging in oak barrels. This Port is aged in oak barrels for a minimum of 10 years, which gives it more time to oxidize and integrate the oak’s influence. Over this extended aging period, the wine develops more complex flavors, including nutty, caramel, and dried fruit notes. It becomes smoother, with a more pronounced aged character compared to Reserve Tawny.
Splurge: Graham’s 20 yr. Tawny ($70+)
Graham’s 20 Year Old Tawny Port is a luxurious, complex wine that exemplifies the finesse of long aging in oak barrels. With its rich flavors of dried fruit, caramel, nuts, and spices, it represents a perfect balance of sweetness and acidity. This Tawny Port offers an elegant, velvety texture and a long, satisfying finish, making it an ideal choice for special occasions, or as an after-dinner treat. It is particularly delightful when paired with rich cheeses, decadent desserts, or simply enjoyed on its own.
Tips for Thanksgiving Wine Pairing
Offer Variety: Provide at least one white, one red, and possibly a sparkling wine to cater to diverse tastes.
Consider Acidity: Wines with higher acidity pair well with Thanksgiving dishes’ rich and sweet flavors.
Chill Reds Slightly: Serving reds slightly cooler than room temperature helps highlight their fruitiness (think 60-65 degrees as the wine will warm as it sits in the glass).
No tannins: Tannic wines, which are wines high in tannins (like Cabernet Sauvignon, Nebbiolo, or Syrah), tend not to pair well with many traditional Thanksgiving foods. For Thanksgiving, wines with lower tannin levels and more balance—such as Pinot Noir, Gamay (Beaujolais), Chardonnay, or Riesling—tend to be more successful. These wines complement the meal’s diverse flavors without overwhelming any single component, making them versatile choices for a wide range of traditional Thanksgiving dishes.
No matter your budget, the right wine can transform your Thanksgiving meal into an unforgettable celebration. Cheers to making memories and savoring every sip!