A Different Wine, a Different Page in the Mental Rolodex

“There’s no fruit.”

“This wine is terrible. It must be corked!”

Dinner with friends had barely reached the first sip when our wine conversation took an unexpected turn.

Lately, we’ve been enjoying Burgundies and taking a deeper dive into Oregon Pinot Noir—exploring regions, vineyards, and the many expressions of a grape that gives us plenty to discuss. For this dinner, I decided to change things up.

I opened a 2021 red Bordeaux from Graves, a second wine from a château. At around $40, it was intended to be an enjoyable bottle with dinner. Nothing grand. Just a change of scenery.

The first reactions caught me off guard. These were friends with experienced palates, and I hadn’t yet tasted the wine myself. If someone suspected cork taint, I wanted to pay attention.

I looked at the ruby wine in my glass, swirled, and sniffed. The nose was reserved, but I didn’t detect the musty character that would have reinforced the concern about cork taint. With air and a little time, aromas began to emerge. I found fruit, a dusty, savory character I associate with Graves, and a soft, approachable wine.

For me, it was sound and enjoyable: a perfectly pleasant Tuesday-night Bordeaux.

What stayed with me was how quickly we had reached the question of a fault. I wondered whether our recent run of Pinot Noir had left us expecting something different from the wine now in our glasses.

We all carry a mental wine Rolodex. Over time, we collect memories of aromas, flavors, textures, and the bottles that gave us pleasure. Those memories help us recognize what we’re drinking. Sometimes, though, we may still have the previous card at the front of the file.

That’s where taking a moment to look at the bottle can help.

This wasn’t a blind tasting. The label was available to give us our bearings: Bordeaux, Graves, 2021. That information could prompt a useful pause. What have I encountered in wines like this before? Am I finding fruit beneath the savory elements? Does the wine need a little air? What, specifically, makes me suspect a fault?

The label doesn’t answer those questions for us. It gives us somewhere to begin looking.

There’s a distinction here between finding fruit in a wine and describing the wine as “fruity.” Fruit can be present without leading the conversation. Earthy or savory qualities may speak first, with the fruit becoming clearer as we spend time with the glass.

Of course, a familiar appellation cannot guarantee a sound bottle. Cork taint can be subtle, sometimes muting fruit without an obvious musty smell. A suspicion deserves attention. But giving that suspicion a little time—and looking for evidence—can help us reach a more considered judgment.

And recognizing a wine’s style doesn’t oblige anyone to enjoy it. We can understand what’s in the glass and still prefer something else.

For me, the evening was a reminder of how useful our accumulated wine memories can be, provided we pause long enough to consult them. Look at the bottle. Turn a few cards in that mental Rolodex. Swirl, taste, and revisit.

Sometimes a change of wine simply asks us to find our bearings again.

Thanksgiving Wine Pairing: A Few Tips to Keep Everyone Happy

Thanksgiving may be the most challenging meal of the year when it comes to choosing wine. Think about what’s on the table: turkey, stuffing, mashed potatoes, gravy, sweet potatoes, cranberry sauce, and perhaps a few family favorites that make an appearance only once a year.

That’s a lot of competing flavors!

The good news is that you don’t need an expensive bottle or an encyclopedic knowledge of wine to find something that works. Here are four simple tips to help you navigate the wine selections.

1. Offer a Little Variety

If you’re entertaining a crowd, consider offering a white, a red, and perhaps a sparkling wine or rosé. But don’t feel obligated to offer an entire wine shop! A thoughtfully selected white and red will make most guests perfectly happy.

For a white, I’d steer away from the particularly sharp, grassy style of New Zealand Sauvignon Blanc and look instead toward a California Sauvignon Blanc, especially one that includes a little Sémillon. The Sauvignon Blanc offers refreshing acidity, while Sémillon can contribute richness and texture, creating a wine that stands up beautifully to Thanksgiving’s substantial flavors.

2. Acidity Is Your Friend — But Balance Is the Goal

Acidity refreshes your palate between bites, especially when enjoying rich foods such as buttery mashed potatoes, gravy, and stuffing.

But there’s a difference between refreshing acidity and acidity that seems razor-sharp. That crisp, bracing wine you loved with oysters on a summer afternoon might not be your favorite companion for turkey and all the trimmings.

Look for wines with enough acidity to keep things lively, but also some roundness and fruit concentration to complement the meal. It’s all about balance.

3. Give Your Red Wines a Little Chill

Here’s a simple trick: serve your reds slightly cooler than typical room temperature, around 60–65°F. Remember, the wine will warm as it sits in the glass.

This is especially true for Beaujolais, a wine long celebrated as a Thanksgiving companion. Made from the Gamay grape, Beaujolais generally offers bright fruit, lively acidity, and gentle tannins. A slight chill makes those fresh fruit flavors come alive and refreshes the palate between bites.

4. Go Easy on the Tannins

Tannins contribute structure to red wine and create that drying sensation you sometimes feel along your gums and tongue.

Ever left a tea bag steeping too long? That increasingly bitter, drying sensation is a good illustration of astringency from tannins.

Powerfully tannic wines, such as some Cabernet Sauvignon, Nebbiolo, and Syrah, can be challenging with the many flavors of Thanksgiving dinner, particularly sweeter dishes.

Instead, consider reds with gentler tannins, such as Pinot Noir or Gamay (Beaujolais). For whites, Chardonnay, Riesling, and Sauvignon Blanc blends can be wonderful companions.

And Finally, Don’t Overthink It!

Thanksgiving is about gathering around the table, enjoying good food, sharing stories, and making memories.

Whether you’re opening a modestly priced bottle or something you’ve been saving for a special occasion, remember that the company around the table matters far more than the price of the wine.

Choose wines you enjoy, offer a little variety, and don’t worry about finding that one elusive perfect pairing. With so many dishes on the table, there probably isn’t just one!

Happy Thanksgiving, and cheers to making memories and savoring every sip!

When History Sneaks Into the Glass

I spent an evening evaluating a lineup of old Napa Cabernets and kept returning to the oldest wine in the lineup. Remarkably well made for its age, it continued to hold my attention. The next morning, I learned I had been drinking the inaugural vintage of Opus One.


At a Glance

Wine: Opus One 1979
Age: 46 Years
Color: Garnet with sediment; brighter than expected
Aromas: Mint, bottle-aged complexity, oxidative development
Palate: Faded fruit, integrated oak, retained structure and weight
Conclusion: Past its peak, yet still capable of telling its story


The Bottle That Kept Calling Me Back

Recently, we joined friends for an evening of wine and appetizers. As often happens when longtime collectors begin opening bottles that have accompanied them through decades of life, the table became a walk through Napa Valley history. Among the bottles were Groth, Silver Oak, Inglenook, and several others.

One bottle in particular kept drawing my attention: Opus One 1979.

The cork required an Ah-So to remove. In the glass, the wine showed a garnet color with visible sediment and more brightness than I expected from a 46-year-old Cabernet blend. Before pouring, I spent time smelling the bottle opening, as I often do with older wines. While all the bottles offered interesting aromas, I found myself repeatedly returning to the Opus. Despite its age, there was still a lively layer of complexity rising from the neck of the bottle.

My initial impression in the glass was less encouraging. The nose seemed tired and somewhat reductive, showing minty notes along with a faint moldy character that may have reflected the condition of the cork. The wine was clearly showing oxidative development, yet it was far from dead.


Thirty Minutes Changed Everything

Rather than rush to judgment, I let the wine sit in the glass.

Thirty minutes later, the story changed.

The reductive notes had subsided, revealing a wine that had moved beyond its prime drinking window but still carried evidence of what it once had been. The fruit had largely faded, yet hints of former richness remained. The palate retained respectable weight, the oak had long ago integrated into the wine’s structure, and the finish remained surprisingly intact without the excessive bitterness that old phenolics can sometimes display.

When the group asked what I thought, I replied that for a 46-year-old Napa wine, what remained in the glass demonstrated exceptional craftsmanship. While I personally prefer a wine with more fruit than remained here, the fact that it was still drinkable—and still interesting—spoke volumes about its quality.

“Even in a bottle that was clearly past its peak, the wine still possessed enough structure, balance, and character to communicate its origins.”


The Morning After

The surprise came the next morning.

While reading about the partnership between Robert Mondavi and Baron Philippe de Rothschild, I discovered that 1979 was the inaugural vintage of Opus One.

Only then did I realize I had spent the evening with a piece of California wine history.

What struck me most was that I had evaluated the wine before I knew its significance. Had I known I was tasting the debut vintage of one of Napa Valley’s most influential wines, it would have been easy to view it through the lens of reputation. Instead, I simply tasted what was in the glass.

Interestingly, I later discovered that other well-preserved bottles of the 1979 vintage are still showing enough life to impress experienced critics. My bottle was likely more evolved, a reminder that bottle variation becomes increasingly significant as wines approach half a century of age. Yet that fact only reinforced my conclusion.


Why Old Wine Matters

It no longer shouted, but it still had a voice.

As wine lovers, we often ask whether an old wine is still alive. The 1979 Opus One reminded me that perhaps the better question is whether a wine still has a story to tell.

This one did.

Burgundy’s Quiet Shift: From Extraction to Infusion

Why many Burgundian winemakers are stepping back in the cellar to reveal Pinot Noir’s true character.

Across Burgundy, a subtle change is taking place. Instead of extracting more from Pinot Noir, many winemakers are discovering that patience in the cellar may reveal even more about the vineyard.


A Personal Observation

While preparing several Burgundy masterclasses for 2026, I found myself thinking about how much the conversation around Pinot Noir has changed over the past two decades. When I first began studying Burgundy, much of the technical discussion centered on extraction—how winemakers managed fermentation to build structure and ageability.

Today, however, many producers speak about something quite different: infusion.

The shift may sound subtle, but it reflects a meaningful evolution in how Burgundy’s winemakers approach the cellar.


Extraction vs. Infusion

In wine, meaningful changes rarely announce themselves loudly. More often, they appear gradually—one cellar decision at a time—until suddenly the style of an entire region feels different.

In Burgundy, that shift is happening now.

For decades, discussions about red Burgundy centered on extraction: how much color, tannin, and structure could be drawn from Pinot Noir’s thin skins during fermentation.

Punch-downs, pump-overs, and maceration length were tools used to shape wines that would age gracefully and develop complexity over time.

Historically, extraction in Burgundy was not simply stylistic but practical. In cooler vintages, winemakers often needed to work the cap more actively to build sufficient color and structure from Pinot Noir’s naturally thin skins.

But today, a different philosophy is quietly taking hold across the Côte d’Or. Increasingly, winemakers speak not about extraction, but about infusion.

Extraction implies force. It suggests actively drawing phenolics—color, tannin, and flavor—from the skins during fermentation.

Infusion, by contrast, is a more patient approach. Instead of aggressively working the cap of skins and stems that rises during fermentation, many producers now favor a gentler method. The goal is to allow the wine to gradually absorb structure and aromatics rather than pulling them out through mechanical intervention.

The difference may sound subtle, but in the glass it can be profound.

Infusion often yields wines that feel more transparent and aromatic, with tannins that are fine-grained rather than muscular. Instead of emphasizing power, the wines emphasize nuance.


Infusion and the Shape of Tannins

Another way to think about the difference between extraction and infusion is through the shape of tannins.

Extraction tends to emphasize quantity. Techniques such as frequent punch-downs or aggressive cap management draw more phenolic compounds from the skins and seeds, often creating wines with firmer, more assertive tannic structure.

Infusion, by contrast, is less about how much tannin enters the wine and more about how those tannins integrate. When phenolics dissolve gradually during fermentation—rather than being actively forced out—the resulting tannins can feel finer, more supple, and more evenly woven into the wine.

In practical terms, the wine may not contain less tannin. Instead, the tannins feel different: less angular, more layered, and often more transparent to the vineyard character beneath them.

Because infusion slows the extraction process, it also gives the winemaker more time to observe how the wine is evolving during fermentation. Rather than forcing structure early, the cellar team can allow the wine to develop gradually and intervene only when necessary.

For Pinot Noir, a grape variety prized for its ability to express place, this difference can be critical. The goal is not to eliminate structure, but to shape it in a way that supports the wine rather than dominating it.


Infusion isn’t about extracting less from Pinot Noir — it’s about shaping the tannins differently.


Whole Cluster: Not Just a Beaujolais Technique

The use of whole-cluster fermentation—where grape bunches are placed into the fermenter with stems intact—is sometimes mistakenly associated with Beaujolais.

In Beaujolais, whole clusters are frequently used to encourage carbonic or semi-carbonic fermentation, a process that emphasizes bright fruit and the famously playful aromas often associated with Gamay.

While both Burgundy and Beaujolais may ferment whole clusters, the intention is very different.

In Burgundy, whole-cluster fermentation primarily influences structure, aromatic lift, and fermentation dynamics rather than fruitiness alone. The intact clusters create natural channels within the fermenting must, allowing juice to circulate more gently and encouraging a slower, more gradual infusion of phenolics.

The stems themselves can contribute subtle spice, floral lift, and a distinctive structural backbone to Pinot Noir. When stems are fully ripe—as they increasingly are in warmer growing seasons—they can enhance freshness and complexity rather than introducing bitterness.

In this context, whole-cluster fermentation becomes less about fruitiness and more about texture, aromatic lift, and balance.


Why the Change?

Several forces are driving this shift.

Climate change is one of the most significant. Warmer growing seasons mean that Pinot Noir reaches phenolic ripeness more reliably than it once did. When skins and stems are already mature, there is less need to force structure through extraction.

At the same time, the next generation of Burgundian winemakers has begun taking the reins from their parents and grandparents. Many of these younger producers have inherited not only vineyards but also global demand and escalating land prices. Their challenge is not to make bigger wines, but to preserve the elegance that defines Burgundy’s identity.

In that context, restraint becomes a virtue.


A Region Defined by Patience

Burgundy has long been a region defined by nuance rather than force. As a new generation of winemakers takes the reins—while also navigating climate change, rising vineyard costs, and global demand—their response has often been to do less, not more.

The shift from extraction to infusion reflects that philosophy. Instead of shaping Pinot Noir through aggressive cellar work, many producers now allow the wine to reveal itself gradually.

In Burgundy, patience may prove to be the most powerful tool of all.


Author

Claire L. Torbeck, DipWSET, writes Sudsy’s Cellar to explore how climate, vineyard practice, and winemaking philosophy shape the wines we enjoy.

The Evolving Landscape of Global Wine: Climate vs. Market

Wine has always evolved. But over the past several decades, the pace—and direction—of stylistic change has accelerated. Across the globe, wines have grown riper, darker, more structured, and often more oak-influenced. Alcohol levels have edged upward. Texture and immediacy increasingly take precedence over restraint.

The question many wine professionals quietly ask is this:
Are these changes driven primarily by climate change—or by market forces shaped by critics, scores, and consumer demand?

The honest answer is not either/or. It is both.


Where Climate Ends and Choice Begins

Climate change is no longer abstract in the vineyard; it is measurable and unavoidable. Earlier budbreak, compressed growing seasons, rising sugar levels, faster phenolic development, and increasing water stress are now common realities across many of the world’s established wine regions.

These shifts naturally influence grape composition and harvest decisions. In many cases, wines are becoming riper not by design, but by necessity.

Yet climate alone does not dictate style.

While environmental conditions define what is possible, they do not determine what is pursued. That distinction belongs to the winemaker—and, increasingly, to the market.


The Market Pull: When Style Becomes Strategy

As global wine markets expanded, a powerful feedback loop emerged between critics, scores, and consumer expectations. Wines that were richer, more expressive, and immediately impactful tended to score well—and sell well. Over time, stylistic preferences hardened into commercial strategy.

Oak regimes shifted. Extraction increased. Alcohol levels crept upward. Even regions historically associated with restraint began producing wines designed to perform on release rather than evolve quietly over time.

These changes were not inherently negative. They were, in many cases, pragmatic responses to a competitive global marketplace. But they also blurred distinctions between regions, encouraging a convergence of style that made wines more recognizable—and sometimes more interchangeable.

The most consequential moment occurs when climate pressure and market incentives move in the same direction. Warmer growing conditions naturally produce riper fruit; market demand rewards richness and intensity. What appears inevitable can, in fact, be amplified by choice.


Same Region, Two Philosophies: Rioja

Few regions illustrate this intersection of climate, market forces, and human intention more clearly than Rioja DOCa.

For much of its history, traditional Rioja defined itself not by power, but by patience. Long aging in American oak created an oxidative environment where complexity emerged through time rather than fruit intensity. Extended maturation—often carried out at the winery’s expense—allowed wines to develop tertiary aromas of leather, dried fruit, tobacco, and earth. These wines were typically medium-bodied, softly structured, and released only when considered ready to drink.

Modern Rioja reflects a different set of priorities. While remaining within DOCa aging requirements, many producers shifted toward French oak, shorter maturation cycles, reduced maceration, and increased focus on freshness and structure. Fruit expression became more pronounced; tannins firmer; acidity brighter. Single-varietal bottlings and experimental blends emerged alongside traditional styles.

The result is not a divided region, but a pluralistic one—where philosophy, not regulation, defines expression.


A Quiet Counter-Movement

Alongside these trends, a quieter movement has gained momentum. Some producers, faced with warming conditions, are choosing restraint rather than amplification. Earlier harvests, larger or neutral vessels, gentler extraction, and site-driven decision-making aim to preserve identity rather than polish it away.

These wines may not always dominate tastings or score highest on release. But they reward patience, food, and attention—and they remind us that evolution need not mean homogenization.


Closing: Evolution Is Inevitable. Homogenization Is Not.

Wine will continue to evolve; climate ensures that. But climate does not make stylistic decisions—people do. Vineyard conditions may push grapes toward ripeness, yet it is philosophy, commercial pressure, and producer intent that determine how that ripeness is expressed in the glass.

The most compelling wines today are not defined by whether they are traditional or modern, powerful or restrained. They are defined by clarity of intent. In an era where climate realities and market incentives increasingly align, the risk is not change itself, but convergence—the quiet erosion of distinction in favor of familiarity.

For the drinker, this moment invites curiosity rather than judgment. Asking why a wine tastes the way it does may be more revealing than deciding whether one style is better than another. After all, evolution can deepen identity just as easily as it can blur it—and the difference lies not only in the vineyard, but in the choices made long after the grapes are harvested.

An Exercise in Style: Traditional vs. Modern Rioja

To explore how winemaking philosophy shapes style within a single region, consider tasting wines from producers that represent different approaches within Rioja DOCa. These examples are illustrative rather than prescriptive; they highlight intent, not hierarchy.

Traditional-Leaning Rioja Producers

(Extended aging, American oak influence, late-release philosophy)

  • López de Heredia
    A benchmark for long oxidative aging, American oak, and winery-held releases that prioritize tertiary development and readiness at release.
  • La Rioja Alta
    Classical blending, in-house cooperage, and extended maturation defining traditional Rioja structure, aromatics, and longevity.
  • CVNE
    A historic house whose core bottlings continue to reflect restrained fruit expression and traditional aging practices.

Modern-Leaning Rioja Producers

(Freshness, structure, fruit clarity, and precision)

  • Artadi
    Site-focused wines emphasizing purity of fruit, reduced oak influence, and early clarity of expression.
  • Bodegas Muga
    A compelling example of modern Rioja that retains deep respect for tradition—combining contemporary precision, in-house cooperage, and a focus on freshness and structure.
  • Marqués de Riscal
    A historic estate illustrating how traditional roots can coexist with modern techniques and global markets.

How to Use This Exercise

Taste one wine from each category side by side. Focus not on preference, but on why the wines differ:

  • How does oak choice influence aroma, texture, and perception of freshness?
  • What role does time—both in barrel and bottle—play in complexity versus immediacy?
  • How does each wine communicate its intended moment of consumption?

The goal is not to crown a winner, but to understand how climate, market forces, and producer philosophy intersect to shape what ends up in the glass.


I have recently visited the wineries and vineyards of these producers, offering first-hand insight into how philosophy translates from vineyard to cellar.

“These producers illustrate stylistic choices—not quality hierarchies.”

What Petite Sirah Does to Cabernet—And Why It Matters

“Cabernet Sauvignon is a soloist. So why do so many winemakers keep giving it backup singers?”



In the ever-competitive world of California wine, consistency is currency. With rising expectations from consumers and critics alike, wineries often seek to craft Cabernet Sauvignon wines that are plush, powerful, and polished—vintage after vintage. But in the pursuit of this stylistic consistency, an unlikely grape has become a quiet enabler: Petite Sirah.

Blended in small but influential amounts, Petite Sirah is frequently added to Cabernet to deepen color, round out texture, and stabilize structure. Yet in doing so, it may also be flattening acidity, muting fruit expression, and ultimately dulling the vibrant voice that great Cabernet is capable of singing.

This article explores what Petite Sirah does in the blend, how its use reflects a formulaic winemaking mindset, and why this quiet shift in cellar choices matters—for authenticity, terroir transparency, and the future of expressive wines.

The Quiet Power of Petite Sirah

Petite Sirah (a.k.a. Durif) is a thick-skinned, late-ripening varietal known for its deeply pigmented juice, high tannin content, and bold structure. While seldom bottled on its own in high-end blends, it is a favorite tool for winemakers looking to:
– Intensify color
– Boost tannin grip
– Round out mouthfeel
– Stabilize a wine’s profile

Yet these benefits come with trade-offs. When added to Cabernet—even in small amounts—Petite Sirah can:
– Mute bright red or cassis fruit
– Suppress varietal clarity
– Dampen perceived acidity
– Create a generalized ‘bigness’ rather than detailed expression

As one winemaker privately put it, “It’s the volume button, not the tuning knob.”

From Character to Consistency: The Rise of Formula Wine

In vertical tastings, one can often detect when a wine’s profile becomes more about replicating house style than reflecting vintage variation or vineyard nuance. It’s here that Petite Sirah plays its stealth role.

There are brands that frequently rely on blending components like Petite Sirah, Syrah, or even Zinfandel to maintain plush, rounded profiles. The goal? Appealing mouthfeel, saturated color, and a flavor profile that “delivers” reliably at the retail shelf.

This is the hallmark of what I call formula wine—a blend crafted to meet expectations, not challenge them. And while there’s no shame in making delicious, accessible wine, it raises the question: At what point does formula replace authenticity?

When Cabernet Speaks, Listen Closely

Cabernet Sauvignon, when grown in the right site and allowed to express itself, can be electrifying: lifted aromas of blackcurrant, graphite, tobacco leaf, and violets; vibrant acidity; age-worthy tannin structure. These are the hallmarks of expressive Cabernet—from Napa’s mountain vineyards to Paso’s limestone pockets to Bordeaux’s Left Bank.

But once you’ve tasted a site-pure, unembellished Cabernet, it becomes hard to ignore how muted some blends have become. That exhilarating brightness—what some call “the snap”—can disappear under a thick cloak of color, weight, and indistinct darkness.

I’ve personally tasted Cabernets from producers who add Petite Sirah that feel like flat soda—dense, heavy, and short on lift. The freshness is gone. The fruit is thick, not bright. And while the wine may impress in a tasting lineup, it rarely invites a second glass at the dinner table.

Who’s Doing It Differently: Site Over Style

Fortunately, not all Cabernet producers follow the formula. A growing number of winemakers are leaning into transparency over technique—choosing to let vineyard expression and vintage variation shine, even if that means sacrificing some polish or consistency.

Take producers like Corison in Napa Valley. Cathy Corison’s wines are resolutely varietal, often lower in alcohol, and proudly site-driven. Her Kronos Vineyard Cabernets taste like where they come from—gravelly soils just west of Highway 29, exposed to the diurnal shifts that preserve acidity and aromatic lift.

Ridge Vineyards, while more commonly associated with Zinfandel, produces Cabernets from sites like Monte Bello with admirable restraint, complexity, and no need to “flesh out” the wine with extraneous blending or high-octane stylization.

Producers like Smith-Madrone, Heitz Cellar, Keenan, and Dunn Vineyards offer Cabernets that maintain integrity to site and vintage. These wines resist manipulation, embracing structure, freshness, and varietal clarity—without needing to “supercharge” with Petite Sirah or overdone oak.

These producers understand something critical: that the best Cabernet doesn’t need to be louder—it needs to be clearer.

Perspective and Palate

Let’s be clear: wine is ultimately a beverage meant to be enjoyed, and there are many different palates to please. Styled wines absolutely have their place—especially for newer consumers or in restaurant programs, where reliability and approachability are often more important than vintage variation or site expression.

That said, in marketing their brands, some winemakers—particularly in regions like Paso Robles—blend in Syrah or Petite Sirah and present the resulting wines as superior-quality, classic, and ageworthy Cabernets, often described as exquisitely rich and elegant, capable of rivaling their famous French counterparts.

Are those claims justified? That’s a question each consumer, sommelier, or collector must answer for themselves. But asking the question is part of being an engaged wine drinker—and part of honoring the diversity of what Cabernet Sauvignon can be.

Why It Matters

The use of Petite Sirah in Cabernet might seem like a minor cellar decision. But in the broader context of modern winemaking, it represents a choice: Are we crafting wines to reflect a place—or to meet a profile?

When the goal is to achieve consistency at all costs, we drift into a territory where wines are built, not born. And while there is undoubtedly a place for plush, approachable styles, the danger lies in the erasure of nuance and identity. As blending becomes a tool for engineering sameness, we risk losing the very character that makes great Cabernet—from Howell Mountain to Happy Canyon—so compelling.

As a wine judge, writer, and sommelier, I’ve come to value wines that tell the truth—even when that truth is leaner, edgier, or more angular than expected. I’d rather taste the vineyard in a minor key than hear the same chorus on repeat.

Petite Sirah is not the villain. But its quiet role in muting Cabernet’s natural voice deserves more attention—and more conversation.

Final Sip

If you’ve opened a bottle of Cabernet lately and found it heavy, indistinct, or curiously lifeless, ask yourself: Is this wine speaking, or has its voice been replaced?

Wine doesn’t need to shout to be heard. Sometimes, all it needs is the courage to be itself.

Author’s Note

This piece reflects one sommelier’s perspective on how blending choices and stylistic decisions can shape the personality of a wine. It’s not a criticism of blending or of winemakers who pursue a consistent house style — rather, it’s a reflection on how expression, balance, and individuality can coexist within the craft of winemaking.

Exploring Chablis Grands Crus: A Masterclass Overview

The Lake Tahoe chapter has elevated member education with a series of ambitious masterclasses—2010 Bordeaux by Left Bank appellation; the wines of R. López de Heredia; a cross-vintage Bordeaux comparison (2000, 2010, 2020); a curated flight from Wine Spectator’s 2024 Top 100 with pairings; and, most recently, a focused tasting of the seven Grands Crus of Chablis.

Hosted by Julie and Craig Rauchle at their home overlooking Lake Tahoe, the August program was presented by Claire Torbeck, DipWSET, Certified Sommelier, and Chapter Wine Director. The Grand Cru wines took time to source—several were acquired directly from France—and we were fortunate to present all 2022s across the seven climats (Les Clos, Vaudésir, Valmur, Les Preuses, Bougros, Blanchot, Grenouilles), which together form the single Chablis Grand Cru AOC.

We opened with a two-glass warm-up to frame style vs. site. Volunteers Craig Rauchle and Wally Binder shared observations using a custom tasting sheet designed to separate winemaking style levers (malolactic fermentation, lees stirring, and new oak) from site cues (acid line, salinity, and limestone texture).

  • Wine 1: Rombauer Chardonnay (California)—our example of a crafted, consistent style, shaped by full MLF, barrel fermentation/aging, lees stirring, and generous new oak, yielding the familiar buttery, toasty profile across vintages.
  • Wine 2: Domaine Pinson, Chablis 1er Cru Fourchaume—a site-driven contrast from a cool climate and Kimmeridgian limestone (marl rich in fossilized seashells), with restrained winemaking and naturally high acidity letting the vineyard speak.

Armed with that “map,” the group tasted through the seven Chablis Grand Cru climats, exploring how aspect, contour, and limestone depth channel fruit profile, line, and length. Set on the right-bank slope above the Serein River, the concentration of Kimmeridgian marl and minimalistic élevage combined to spotlight tension, salinity, and crystalline precision—classic Chablis signatures that distinguish these wines from richer, oak-forward styles.

We concluded with a lakeside buffet curated by Julie Rauchle, whose pairings—saline, citrus, and lightly creamy elements—echoed the wines’ structure. A final glass of 2021 Domaine Pinson Chablis 1er Cru Fourchaume offered a graceful bridge from Grand Cru power to Premier Cru finesse—an elegant coda to a rigorous and delicious masterclass.

Learning Outcomes (what members took away)

  • Confidently explain style vs. site using clear levers (MLF/lees/oak) and cues (acid/salinity/chalky texture).
  • Name the seven Grand Cru climats and understand that they comprise the single Chablis Grand Cru AOC.
  • Describe how Kimmeridgian limestone and cool climate shape Chablis: high acidity, mineral line, and length.
  • Articulate why Chablis Grands Crus differ from oak-driven styles like classic California Chardonnay.

As the chapter’s Wine Director, Claire Torbeck, DipWSET, Certified Sommelier, conceived, curated, and presented all of the masterclasses noted above—including 2010 Left Bank Bordeaux, R. López de Heredia, the 2000/2010/2020 Bordeaux comparison, the 2024 Top 100 tasting with pairings, and the Seven Grands Crus of Chablis. From designing curricula and tasting frameworks to sourcing allocations and leading the sessions, Claire oversees the program end-to-end and will continue to develop rigorous, engaging masterclasses for members of the IWFS Lake Tahoe.

The Rise of High ABV Wines: A Challenge for Napa Valley

In the midst of a global shift toward moderation in alcohol consumption, it’s hard not to raise an eyebrow at the persistence of 15.5% ABV wines — particularly from regions like Napa Valley. As consumers increasingly seek balance, freshness, and food-friendly wines, one wonders: Has Napa missed the memo?

“Elegance isn’t weakness; it’s refinement. And that may just be Napa’s next great challenge.”

There was a time when Cabernet Sauvignon from Napa struck a beautiful balance — supple, expressive, and food-compatible. Today, many bottlings surge past 15% alcohol, delivering power, yes — but also a palate burn that lingers long after the last sip. Try pairing that with a classic roast or even a modest charcuterie board, and the match often falls apart. At a recent visit, several producers spoke proudly of crafting powerful, extracted wines aligned to critical scoring systems — still chasing ratings.

So, why the stubborn trend toward elevated alcohol?

It’s partly historical. Napa’s success in the 1990s and early 2000s was built on boldness — ripe fruit, generous oak, and big scores. Critics rewarded volume and weight. But that style, while once fashionable, feels out of sync with the current wine climate — both literally and figuratively.

Climate change hasn’t helped. Warmer seasons push sugar accumulation ahead of phenolic development. Winemakers either harvest early and risk green flavors, or wait and face wines that spiral past 15.5% ABV. Without thoughtful viticulture — canopy adjustments, rootstock selection, maybe even vineyard relocation — the default path is often more alcohol.

“High alcohol isn’t just a number — it’s a sensory force that can overshadow nuance, dull acidity, and exhaust the palate.”

And yet, around the world, we see producers adapting. Burgundy’s elegance remains intact through strategic vineyard management. Champagne producers manage ripeness while preserving freshness. Even in historically warm regions like Priorat, stylistic shifts are underway toward lift and restraint.

To be fair, Napa is not static. Some producers are shifting. We see lighter expressions emerging from mountain AVAs and cooler pockets like Coombsville. But as long as high-alcohol styles are rewarded by critics and expected by collectors, many wineries remain locked into that identity.

In today’s wine culture — where sustainability, health, and food pairing matter more than ever — there’s a growing place for wines that speak softly rather than shout.

More concerning than the sheer alcohol percentage is the imbalance it creates in the glass. Alcohol is inherently sweet, and when combined with ripe fruit or residual sugar, the perception of sweetness intensifies — even in ostensibly dry wines. To compensate, many producers lean into heavier oak usage, which can impart bitterness when layered over high alcohol and dense fruit. Instead of harmony, the wine can feel fragmented — with sweetness, bitterness, and warmth competing for dominance, while acidity, the lifeline of structure and refreshment, gets lost in the mix.

“Balance doesn’t mean less — it means more of what matters: freshness, structure, and soul.”

While Napa often favors an opulent, high-alcohol style in its Cabernet Sauvignon — showcasing ripe fruit, rich tannins, and generous oak — regions such as Burgundy and many cool-climate zones in California emphasize restraint and elegance, particularly in Chardonnay and Pinot Noir. These wines offer finesse, vibrancy, and nuance. They may not shout, but they sing.

Both styles have their place. Opulence appeals to consumers who seek intensity and richness. Restraint caters to those who prefer freshness and delicacy. Importantly, neither style is inherently superior; rather, they reflect differences in climate, vineyard management, winemaking philosophy, and market demand.

With climate change driving warmer vintages and consumers seeking moderation and balance, Napa has an opportunity — and a responsibility — to evolve. We’re already seeing signs of that. A new chapter of Napa winemaking could embrace diversity of style, with both opulent and restrained Cabernets thriving side by side.


Exploring Tre Bicchieri: Italy’s Top Wine Awards and Tastings

Tre Bicchieri is one of Italy’s most prestigious wine awards, given by the renowned Italian wine guide Gambero Rosso. The term translates to “three glasses,” signifying wines that stand out for their exceptional quality. Each year, Gambero Rosso also hosts a tasting tour featuring the award-winning wines, and the San Francisco event took place on February 27, 2025, at Fort Mason. It’s a fantastic opportunity for industry professionals to explore top-tier Italian wines and engage with winemakers, distributors, and brand representatives.

My Tasting Strategy

With hundreds of wines available, tasting everything is impossible, so I always attend with a focused plan. This year, I sought out producers that, in my experience, consistently deliver high-quality wines. I approached the tasting relatively blind—meaning I knew the producer but hadn’t researched the wine’s ratings, price, or blend beforehand.

I also narrowed my focus to Italy’s powerhouse appellations—the 3 B’s (Barolo, Barbaresco, Brunello)—along with Chianti, because, well, how could I not?

The Wines

Below is a curated selection of the wines I tasted, along with their vintage, producer, critic ratings, price, and grape composition.

VintageProducer & WineCritic RatingPrice (USD)Blend
2022Il Sasso Carmignano, Mauro VannucciJS 92$3580% Sangiovese, 20% Cabernet Sauvignon
2019Brunello di Montalcino Poggiarelli, CortonesiJS 91$35100% Sangiovese
2019Brunello di Montalcino La Mannella, CortonesiN/A$69100% Sangiovese
2016Brunello di Montalcino La Mannella Riserva, CortonesiN/A$69100% Sangiovese
2021Nizza Le Court Riserva, Michele ChiarloWE 94$50100% Barbera
2020Barolo Cerequio, Michele ChiarloWE 94$124100% Nebbiolo
2019Tenuta di Arceno ArcanumRP 93$5265% Cabernet Franc, 20% Merlot, 15% Cabernet Sauvignon
2020Tenuta di Arceno Chianti Classico RiservaWS 94$40100% Sangiovese
2018Tenuta di Arceno ValadornaRP 95$120100% Merlot
2020Renato Ratti Barolo SerradenariN/A$180100% Nebbiolo
2020Renato Ratti Barolo MarcenascoJD 93$75100% Nebbiolo
2022Renato Ratti Langhe NebbioloN/A$27100% Nebbiolo
2020Giovanni Sordo Barolo PernoWE 90$65100% Nebbiolo
2020Giovanni Sordo BaroloN/A$30100% Nebbiolo
2020Poliziano Nobile di Montepulciano Le CaggioleRV 95$70100% Sangiovese
2021Poliziano Nobile di Montepulciano AsinoneD 93$80100% Sangiovese
2021Marchesi Frescobaldi Chianti Rufina Terraelectae V. Montesodi RiservaD 95$45100% Sangiovese
2021Marchesi Frescobaldi Chianti Rufina Nipozzano V. V RiservaJS 92$3690% Sangiovese, 10% other red varieties
2022Marchesi Frescobaldi Chianti Classico Tenuta PeranoN/A$23100% Sangiovese
2021Carlo Giacosa Barbaresco AsiliJS 95$95100% Nebbiolo
2021Carlo Giacosa Barbaresco MonteficoJS 93$60100% Nebbiolo
2021Carlo Giacosa BarbarescoRV 92$37100% Nebbiolo

Key Takeaways

I intentionally omitted any wines that I wouldn’t personally buy. Every wine on this list was good, very good, or outright outstanding. What I love most is the wide range of price points—proof that great wineries can produce quality wines at multiple levels through strong viticulture and winemaking practices.

Of course, these wines only represent a small selection of what was available at the event. Italy’s wine scene is vast, spanning hundreds of regions, grape varieties, and microclimates, with incredibly talented winemakers. I only wish I had more time!

Final Thoughts

If any of these wines catch your interest, I highly encourage you to seek them out. Whether you’re a seasoned collector or just starting to explore Italian wines, you won’t be disappointed.

Let me know in the comments—have you tried any of these wines? Which Italian producers consistently impress you?

Salute! 🍷

The Evolution of Rioja Wine: Tradition Meets Innovation

Spain’s wine industry has undergone significant transformation, evolving from a land dominated by blended wines to one increasingly focused on single-vineyard expressions. While traditional Rioja has long been defined by its aging classifications—Crianza, Reserva, and Gran Reserva—some producers are carving a different path. Among them, R. Lopez de Heredia Viña Tondonia stands as a beacon of tradition, offering single-vineyard wines while maintaining the prestigious DOCa designation.

Rioja’s climate is unique within Spain. Unlike much of the country, which is dominated by Mediterranean warmth, Rioja benefits from a continental climate, bringing cooler temperatures and increased rainfall. This allows grapes to develop bright acidity, a hallmark of the region’s wines. The towering Cantabrian Mountains play a crucial role in defining Rioja’s terroir, trapping moisture and preventing hot Mediterranean influences from overwhelming the vineyards.

Rioja is divided into three subregions:

  • Rioja Alta (near Haro) – High altitude, producing wines with great acidity.
  • Rioja Alavesa – Slightly lower in elevation and a bit wetter.
  • Rioja Oriental – Warmer, with more Mediterranean influence, resulting in riper fruit and softer acidity.

Haro, the epicenter of Rioja’s wine culture, is home to some of Spain’s most iconic wineries, including Muga, CVNE, La Rioja Alta, and, of course, R. Lopez de Heredia. These wineries cluster in the historic Barrio de la Estación, where wines were historically shipped by rail to the rest of Spain and beyond. The town’s significance in Rioja winemaking history is unparalleled, housing some of the most renowned producers who have shaped the region’s legacy. A joy to visit!

Founded in the late 1800s, R. Lopez de Heredia has steadfastly adhered to time-honored winemaking techniques. Their estate includes the revered Viña Tondonia vineyard, a 100-hectare (250-acre) site uniquely positioned along the Ebro River. The river encircles the vineyard like a moat, providing natural protection and enhancing its microclimate. The name “Tondonia” itself means “round,” reflecting this natural geographical feature.

Unlike many modern Rioja producers who embrace stainless steel fermentation and new French oak, Lopez de Heredia remains committed to traditional methods:

  • Natural Fermentation – Utilizing indigenous yeasts present on the grapes and in the winery.
  • Aging in Old Barrels – In-house cooperage ensures quality control, and extended barrel aging imparts complex oxidative notes.
  • Use of Vine Clippings in Fermentation – Similar to Burgundian whole-cluster fermentation, this practice enhances tannic structure and depth while promoting the presence of natural yeasts in the fermentation process.

While Rioja is best known for its reds, the region also produces remarkable white wines. Lopez de Heredia’s Viña Tondonia Blanco is an extraordinary example, undergoing extended aging to develop rich, nutty, oxidative characteristics akin to Vin Jaune from Jura, traditional Sherry, and aged White Burgundy. Stored in the winery’s special cellar, bottles of each vintage are preserved, showcasing the longevity and evolution of these unique wines.

The winery’s commitment to sustainability is evident throughout their viticulture and winemaking practices:

  • No chemical treatments – They employ cover crops, composting, and manual vineyard work to maintain soil health.
  • Dry farming – Encourages deep root growth, ensuring resilience in drought conditions.
  • Minimal sulfur use – Their wines contain only 50 mg/L of SO2, significantly lower than the EU’s 200 mg/L limit.
  • Spiders as natural pest control – Instead of using chemical pesticides, they allow spiders to thrive in their cellars, reducing unwanted insects.
  • Aging Cellars with Natural Humidity and Temperature Control – Built in the late 1800s, their facilities are designed to naturally regulate conditions for optimal aging.
  • In-House Cooperage – Maintaining their own barrels ensures quality control and minimizes the need for external resources.
  • Lopez de Heredia does not release a Gran Reserva every vintage; only the finest years merit this designation. Among the most legendary vintages is the 1964 Gran Reserva, often hailed as one of the greatest wines of the 20th century. Tasting a 39-year-old bottle of this vintage was a pivotal moment in my personal wine journey—though at the time, I had no idea of its historical significance!

While Lopez de Heredia champions traditional Rioja, modern producers have embraced technological advancements, creating fresher, fruit-forward wines. Examples include:

  • Crianza Wines – Such as those from CVNE, Viña Real, and Muga, which use shorter aging and newer oak to highlight bright fruit flavors.
  • Use of Stainless Steel – Enhancing freshness and preserving varietal purity.
  • French Oak Aging – Many producers opt for French oak to appeal to international palates.

R. Lopez de Heredia Viña Tondonia exemplifies the power of tradition in an evolving wine landscape. Their commitment to time-honored techniques, single-vineyard expressions, and sustainable practices ensures that each bottle tells a story of Rioja’s rich history. Whether comparing their wines to modern counterparts or simply enjoying their beautifully aged releases, one thing is certain: Lopez de Heredia’s wines stand as a testament to the enduring legacy of Rioja.

Have you had the opportunity to taste R. Lopez de Heredia wine? I was able to visit the winery in September during crush to learn first-hand about this historic producer. The restrained alcohol level and the clarity and silky texture that extended aging creates in the wine is amazing. I encourage you to share your thoughts and experiences in the comments below!